Wednesday, July 29, 2026
Home Blog Page 966

U.S. pulls personnel from Ukraine; DHS increases warnings of Russian cyberattacks on U.S. power, communication grid

U.S. officials warn that a Russian attack on Ukraine is likely just days away, and has withdrawn all U.S. personnel from the country. Canada has withdrawn all of its military trainers from the area and urged Canadian families to depart immediately, leaving Ukraine now vulnerable. Most of these remaining allies are now in Poland.

The evacuation spells the end of “Operation Unifier,” a large allied training mission in Ukraine, involving both the United Kingdom and the United States. The Ukrainians are once again on their own, as 100,000 Russian troops surround Ukraine along the vast border, and Ukrainians say that portions of their country are already under Russian control.

But the battle ahead may be untraditional and may take place through noncombat means — especially cyberattacks, economic attacks, and terroristic bomb threats, especially since the United States has warned Russia of economic sanctions should President Vladimir Putin attack Ukraine.

With the United States now under the leadership of a frail president, whose mental capacities are demonstrably diminished, Putin may have plans for cyberattacks against the U.S., should our nation retaliate economically against Russia, as President Joe Biden has vowed.

It may be too late for America’s power plants, electric grids, internet, water treatment, and other infrastructure to harden the security of those economic cornerstones, if such an attack is launched.

“We assess that Russia would consider initiating a cyber attack against the Homeland if it perceived a US or NATO response to a possible Russian invasion of Ukraine threatened its long-term national security,” according to a DHS Intelligence and Analysis bulletin sent to law enforcement agencies on Jan. 23.

The DHS bulletin also said a “range of offensive cyber tools that it could employ against US networks” are available to the Russians. According to CNET.com, “In recent weeks, the Russian government is believed to have initiated a handful of cyberattacks against Ukraine. Last month, hacker groups linked to Russia’s intelligence services were blamed for a cyberattack that defaced dozens of Ukrainian government sites with a message warning the country to ‘be afraid and expect the worst.'”

Such a similar attack on U.S. infrastructure would be seen as an act of war, and would have to be sweeping and done with an element of surprise, otherwise the retaliation by Americans would be crippling to Russia’s own infrastructure.

The threat has been growing: In December, the Department of Homeland Security Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) issued an urgent bulletin: An internet “vulnerability, which is being widely exploited by a growing set of threat actors, presents an urgent challenge to network defenders given its broad use,” according to CISA Director Jen Easterly. “To be clear, this vulnerability poses a severe risk.”

Easterly was referring to a component of software called “Log4j,” a utility that operates in the background of the vast majority of software applications in the United States. Even the Department of Defense uses Log4j.

What does this mean for Alaska? Alaskans may expect to see more activity around its military bases in coming days, more sorties and exercises, as well as more base security.

For a far-flung state like Alaska, the threat of being wholly dependent of shipping for fuel and food over long distances in difficult conditions, makes the threat of a cyberattack more serious concern, especially for rural Alaska, where there are no roads. A cut to the communications system, such as if the cellular network went down, or the jamming of computers that operate the Trans Alaska Pipeline System would necessitate a state disaster declaration or state of emergency. A governor might need to call up the National Guard in such an emergency.

Gov. Mike Dunleavy has already focused on increasing security, requesting $25 million from the Legislature to increase food security in the state, and another $23 million to migrate all state servers to “the cloud,” in the anticipation of major disruptions, such as the one that could occur with Russia and possibly North Korea.

But it would take years to effect the change toward greater food security in Alaska, as well as to harden the state’s servers from being taken down by foreign hackers, even if Dunleavy could get the Legislature to agree.

Whether the Legislature has the clarity to work on this issue is a question. For as much as a cyberattack on the United States is a threat of some magnitude to Alaska, the House Committee on Military and Veterans Affairs on Tuesday will continue its inquisition into the veterans’ group known as the Oath Keepers, with a presentation from Sam Jackson, author of “Oath Keepers: Patriotism and the Edge of Violence in a Right-Wing Antigovernment Group,” and Matthew Kriner, senior research scholar at the Center on Terrorism, Extremism, and Counterterrorism, at Middlebury Institute of International Studies.

Congressman Don Young toughs it out at Mat-Su Republican convention, admits office vaccine mandate

Congressman Don Young made an appearance at the combined Republican conventions for District 27 and 28 on Saturday, held at the Curtis Menard Center in Wasilla, during which he admitted he has a vaccine mandate in his own office.

After he left, his most well-known opponent, Nick Begich, read the actual policy out loud to the room, and then read the termination letter that described the firing of one of Young’s employees because she would not get the Covid vaccine.

The crowd had gathered on Saturday to elect officers and delegates in advance of the April Republican State Convention in Fairbanks.

Young arrived late, and when he spoke, the Republicans had already heard from Begich, who had a number of supporters in the crowd, many of whom had already posted their public endorsements of him. Begich has built tremendous support from the red fortress of Alaska — the Mat-Su. The Young campaign said in response to this story that he arrived on time.

Congressman Young said this year and next will be one of the most important for Alaska and that he still delivers. He said he wanted to dispel rumors that he is not running.

“I’m running hard,” he said. “Because I think it is important to the state. We’ve done the job for the state and I”ll continue to since I’ve been your congressman. My job is to hear you, listen to you, and try to solve your problems. And I’ve been good at that. I’m still good at that.”

Then, speaking apparently of Republican Begich, who was Young’s campaign co-chair for the last election, he said, “Now I don’t blame anybody for trying to run for this seat … I hope they stay positive, if they don’t that’s another story.”

Listen to Congressman Young at this Facebook link.

After Young spoke, members of the audience asked him if he supports vaccine mandates.

Young said, “I don’t think they should be mandated period. I do believe in the vaccine.” He said he grew up with vaccinations but “I don’t believe you should be required to do it. I think that’s wrong, I think it’s overreaching by the federal government … That’s your decision.”

Someone asked if he has an office vaccine mandate and if one of his employees had been fired for refusing the vaccine. He answered, “I do have a vaccine [mandate] for my staff, because there are a lot of people that come into the office. I have lost one employee, uh, she voluntarily left, but I have a vaccine [mandate] for the office.” He also said he would be a “no” vote on any vaccine mandate from the federal government.

Then Begich was given some extra time, because earlier he had been held to a strict time limit.

Congressman Don Young and challenger Nick Begich.

Begich brought out a copy of the Don Young official vaccine mandate and he read the termination letter of the woman who was fired from Young’s office for not taking the Covid vaccine. The crowd was stunned.

“Staff, as you’re aware the congressman implemented an office-wide vaccination policy that was announced yesterday,” Begich read from the letter. “‘Blank,’ (we’ll not mention her name,) has opted not to comply with our vaccination policy and this ends her employment with us effective immediately,” read Begich the memo from Young’s chief of staff in July of 2021.

Begich let that soak in, and then said: “Fired, less than 24 hours after having been given an opportunity to get a vaccine Now we heard the congressman stand up here in front of everyone in this room and say, ‘hey, I’m opposed to vaccine mandates.’ But he had a vaccine mandate and does have a vaccine mandate in his own office. That’s a stone-cold fact and he didn’t deny it — finally.”

Watch Don Young’s address to valley Republicans, he questions he was asked, and Nick Begich then taking questions.

Michael Duxbury: Alaska law enforcement never forgets murdered or missing Native women and children

By MICHAEL DUXBURY

It was with sorrowful satisfaction that I saw the news three days ago of Steven Downs’ conviction and the justice served in the Sophie Sergie cold case in Fairbanks.

I recently wrote to thank Kelly Howell, special assistant to the commissioner of the Department of Public Safety. And she deserves thanks. If it hadn’t been for her realizing our request and being a champion for funding to pursue one of the new approaches to DNA in cold cases, and then asking for additional funding, we would likely not see this develop into a conviction on a 30-year old cold case by the Alaska State Troopers.

It is another example of championing accountability within a justice system that, while it can’t resolve the pain of unspeakable loss, it can pursue justice and some sort of closure on behalf of the victims, their families, and the community.

The conviction of Steven Downs takes down the media-driven narrative that there is any level of ambivalence toward Alaska’s missing and murdered Native women and children.

It has been my experience that AST is not ambivalent about the victims of crime, and never has been. That includes cases of Native missing and/or murdered women. Whenever humanly possible, these cases are pursued.

As the former deputy commissioner and former commander of the Investigative Unit at Alaska State Troopers, I know the Cold Case Unit’s supervisor and Investigator Randy McPherron was relentless in the pursuit of justice for victims. He took the major initial steps in revitalizing the Sophie Sergie cold case homicide.

Investigator McPherron brought the idea of paying for the new DNA investigative tools to me when I was captain commander of Investigations.

McPherron had grit. He took an almost completely gutted Cold Case Section (down to one person due to budget cuts) and re-engage a case that had seen multiple investigators come and go over nearly three decades, and turn it into a unit with the prowess to pursue the DNA. It was his idea about how to effectively serve Alaska and Alaskans according to his oath as efficiently as possible, even in lean budgetary times.

His request of me to approach Howell for funds for this new DNA process turned out to be the best money I ever asked for — and Howell recognized it was the correct path right away.

Investigator McPherron spearheaded a process that rekindled the work of prior investigators and helped shatter the media-manufactured misconception about ambivalence toward missing and murdered Native women and children in Alaska. These are the lives of our neighbors mothers, sisters, aunts, and grand mothers. In AST I knew no one who was ambivalent about these cases.

When Commissioner Amanda Price arrived, on McPherron’s urging I asked she approve a request for more funds for more genetic work on similar cold cases.

I am proud of AST that they are able to prove yet again that the Troopers have never taken the murder of Native women and children lightly.

Even training to recognize steps for prevention were part of DPS procedures, through programs like Katie Tepas’ training of troopers, police, and village public safety officers. The village public safety officers have been part of the efforts to stem these tragedies and, while AST is not perfect, the division is always learning, always trying to improve.

Learning to recognize we can never stop looking for ways to interdict the violence, and that we must be committed in our pursuit of intimate partner and domestic violence crimes have been hallmarks of the Department of Public Safety and Alaska State Troopers.

Another example of how far the Troopers are willing to go to solve murders of indigenous females was evident in the Ashley Barr abduction and homicide case.

The Troopers were “all hands on deck,” asking all law enforcement partners for help. Transportation cost alone was over $200,000 for search dogs, personnel, and equipment to get into Kotzebue, an enormous sum for the department, but needed to investigate the death of little Ashley.

Human capital devastation is a clinical description of the impact to those directly involved as victims, the family, and community, and also members of search teams, and responders, and investigators. The human costs and spending are both reasons to engage in preventative efforts. The senseless loss of precious lives is what AST seeks to prevent in their effort to train Troopers, police officers, and VPSOs throughout the state.

As has been traditional for AST, the Ashley Barr case and the Sophie Sergie case garnered the support of the senior leadership. That resulted sending the lieutenant to help and be the face of the investigations, allowing investigators to spend uninterrupted time on the case. In the Ashley Barr case, I went to Kotzebue as the captain commander to demonstrate our acknowledgement of the case’s importance within the Native community.

With programs like the Violence Against Women Act and the Commissioner’s office Council on Domestic Violence and Sexual Assault, AST has pursued justice-driven accountability for all of Alaska’s victims of violent crime. Diane Casto, the director of CDVSA, is a tireless advocate for these victims.

This recent court conviction of Downs is due to AST’s complete dedication of many, such as Major David Hanson, investigators like McPherron, other troopers, budget, support from Howell, and original investigators.

However, what the public tends to forget is that behind the names or programs most known in association with an investigation, there is a network of selfless public servants who are never recognized — clerks, technicians, computer experts, and those who answer the phones.

AST can point to these recent accomplishments in high-profile cases with bittersweet sorrow and compassion for the victims and their families, and yet with humble pride, as these professionals continue on with their efforts in so many more cases that must be solved.

I hope the Department of Public Safety and the Governor’s Office will consider an award for Investigator McPherron, and for all DPS members. It’s important that they know their contributions to justice are recognized.

Again, congratulations to the many Alaska State Troopers, past and present, who were part of this effort and accomplishment. And congratulations and thanks to the team in the District Attorneys’ Offices who brought these cases to trial.

Michael Duxbury is a retired deputy commissioner of Public Safety and affiliated with UAA’s Arctic Domain Awareness Center as an executive counselor.

Former Alaska Supreme Court Justice Stowers passes

17

Former Alaska Chief Justice Craig F. Stowers died at age 67 on Feb. 10, 2022. He had retired from the Alaska Supreme Court in 2020.

A conservative jurist not swayed by the politics of the day, Stowers was appointed to the court by former Gov. Sean Parnell in 2009 to replace Justice Robert Estaugh. He became the state’s 18th Chief Justice.

Stowers was born in Daytona Beach, Fla., was educated on the East Coast, and first arrived in Alaska in 1977 as a National Park Service ranger at then-McKinley National Park, now Denali National Park and Preserve. He earned his law degree from University of California Davis School of Law, and returned to Alaska, where he co-founded the law firm Clapp Peterson and Stowers. Former Gov. Frank Murkowski appointed Stowers in 2004 as a judge in the Third Judicial District in Anchorage.

In 2009, then-Gov. Sean Parnell appointed Stowers to the Alaska Supreme Court, where he served until announcing his retirement in January, 2020, to be effective June 1.

Stowers had in the past served as president of the board of Christian Health Associates, was on the boards of the Alaska Natural History Association (Alaska Geographic), Brother Francis Shelter, and Anchorage Neighborhood Health Center. He was married to Monique Stowers; the two were known for their charitable giving to many causes, among them the Food Bank of Alaska.

“I was saddened to learn of Justice Stowers’ passing. As Alaskans, we are grateful for his service to Alaska’s people in the judiciary and we offer our condolences to Justice Stowers’ family, friends, and colleagues,” said former Gov. Parnell.

Canadian judge orders truckers to unblock border bridge, but they don’t; judge orders Christian fundraising site to freeze aid to truckers, but it says it won’t

21

GiveSendGo said on Twitter that it won’t comply with the Canadian court order to not give over $8.6 million in donated funds to the group that is aiding truckers in their protest against Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s vaccine mandates.

“Know this! Canada has absolutely ZERO jurisdiction over how we manage our funds here at GiveSendGo,” the group wrote. “All funds for EVERY campaign on GiveSendGo flow directly to the recipients of those campaigns, not least of which is The Freedom Convoy campaign.”

Since the protesting convoy arrived in Ottawa more than two weeks ago, similar convoys have popped up across the globe as workers rise up against their governments’ Covid-19 restrictions. In Canada, truckers are now blocking three border crossings with the United States as of early Saturday morning.

Also on Friday, BBC reported that the Ontario Superior Court of Justice granted the city of Windsor and the Automotive Parts Manufacturers’ Association an injunction that orders the truckers to end the gridlock on the Windsor Ambassador Bridge connecting Windsor to Detroit. On early Saturday morning the bridge was still blockaded.

Numerous smaller American convoys have cropped up from Alaska to Florida in support of the Canadian truckers.

There appears to be a new American convoy starting soon, truckers in the United States northern states said on Friday they would soon hit the road on the I-90 corridor,  which is the longest Interstate Highway in the United States, spanning 3,020 miles across 13 states from Washington state to the northeastern states. The convoy is apparently starting in Spokane, Wash. and ending in Washington, D.C. Details were scarce on Friday night.

How dare you! Ketchikan gets dose of cancel culture over western wear at basketball game with Metlakatla

In a rainforest town where there are no cowboys, and few, if any, horses, high school kids dressing up in western wear has caused great offense to some in the neighboring Alaska Native town of Metlakatla, also a place bereft of horses, cows, and cowboys. Those offended took to social media to declare the Ketchikan students racist.

The pep club for the Ketchikan High School has explained that it had simply chosen “country” as its theme, and so everyone dressed up in whatever western wear could be found in a town that has more Uniroyal boots than residents, and where fishing, boat repair, and tourism are the main economies.

One social media post about the event shows a person was not amused by the theme.

The Ketchikan High School Pep Club has now sent an apology to Metlakatla for wearing western gear at the recent high school basketball game between the two schools:

“On behalf of the Kayhi Pep Club and student body participating in the student section, we would like to apologize and discuss the incidents occurring this past weekend at the KHS I MHS boys basketball games. Our intentions were not malicious. In retrospect and upon reflection, there was an underlying offensive connection to historical atrocities. We fully acknowledge the cultural insensitivity of the theme and apologize for the harm that it has caused toward Metlakatla and in our own community.

“As we are working to understand your perspective, we humbly ask you to hear our perspective. The Pep Club theme, ‘Country’, was randomly selected with no intention of it being interpreted as ‘Cowboys v lndians’. The country theme is one that we’ve used repeatedly in the past including this October. To address the confusion around some of the ‘weird’ or odd noises that were heard by the crowd, embarrassingly, it is simply a habit that we’ve been doing every game this year to bark like dogs at the opposing team to try and distract them from shooting free throws.

“We can not go back in time and correct our misguided decisions, but we can move forward and learn from our mistakes. As a club, we have discussed our current practices related to decision-making regarding event themes and have outlined new approval processes which include checks for sensitivity relating to culture, race, and gender. We have identified a lack of cultural humility within our school and are committed to working with school administration, tribal leaders, and community stakeholders to identify meaningful opportunities to gain knowledge, understanding and rebuild trust among our student body, school staff, community, and neighbors. We regret our actions and look forward to discussing opportunities for growth, as individuals and a community, from this experience.”

Honest mistake? Jury will decide if New York Times defamed former Gov. Sarah Palin

Before a jury that a federal judge had already prejudiced by declaring former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin was, “of course, unvaccinated,” big city attorneys made their closing arguments on Friday. Palin has characterized it as David and Goliath, with her and the people as the Bible’s scrawny David taking on the massive warrior Goliath.

Palin has sued the New York Times for its 2017 editorial that linked a 2011 mass shooting in Arizona to a political map published by Palin’s Sarah PAC political action committee. The jury deliberated Friday and has not yet reached a verdict about the alleged defamation.

New York Times attorney David Axelrod argued on Friday that the hit job on Palin in the editorial, titled “America’s Lethal Politics,” was an “honest mistake. It wasn’t a political hit piece.” He said the staff of the Times was rushing under deadline and that mistakes were made, even by the newspaper’s own fact checker, who did not apparently question the newspaper’s statement that Rep. Gabby Gifford of Arizona was wounded in that 2011 attack because of the Palin PAC map, which showed various congressional districts with targets on them.

The “mistakes” by the New York Times is explained in part by the difference in cultures. Alaska, where Palin is from, is gun country, and targets, along with target practicing, are common. In New York City, however, guns are largely illegal, and there is one remaining gun range in Manhattan, where the trial is being heard.

The editorial, which appeared on June 14, 2017, was written after a liberal gunman shot at Republican members of Congress and staffers during an annual charity baseball game practice in Alexandria, Virginia. The gunman, who had been in protests with the Antifa-precursor “Occupy Wall Street,” had asked people in the baseball field area which persons on the field were Republicans, and then he fired 60 rounds at the Republicans, wounding House Whip Steve Scalise of Louisiana and four others.

The edits to the editorial that day included the assertion that there was a link between the Arizona attack years earlier and political incitement by Palin.

“Before the shooting, Sarah Palin’s political action committee circulated a map of targeted electoral districts that put Ms. Giffords and 19 other Democrats under stylized cross hairs,” the editorial said.

Axelrod pointed out to the jury that a correction was made on the editorial hours later, after Palin and her lawyers had objected.

But the correction was vague and never included the first defamatory information. Palin is asserting that it was a hit job on her all along.

At one point in the trial on Thursday, the New York Times lawyer brought up Palin’s appearance in the show called “The Masked Singer.” The observers in the courtroom laughed at her when she said loudly “Objection,” and the judge advised her that she didn’t have the right to object while she was on the stand. Palin said being on the show allowed her to pay some bills and was the “most fun 90 seconds of my life.” The purpose of Axelrod bringing up the show appeared to be to further damage Palin’s reputation; earlier the clips of the show had been suppressed from the jury because it would have prejudiced them against her.

Palin’s attorney Kenneth Turkel said evidence shows the newspaper was pushing a narrative to damage conservatives when it wrote about her.

“They just didn’t care. She’s one of them [conservatives],” said Turkel. 

From the treatment she received by the New York Times attorney this week, it appears the newspaper still doesn’t care about her reputation, as it used every opportunity to damage Palin in order to protect its right to continue damaging her and other conservatives under the protection of the First Amendment.

Anchorage school lottery is now open

By DAVID BOYLE

The Anchorage School District is holding a lottery for its charter and alternative schools, and now is a chance for parents to help their children get a better opportunity for an education from the public school system.

The district started accepting lottery applications on Feb. 1 for the next school year, which starts in mid-August. The application period ends March 17. A link to the ASD lottery questions and applications can be found here: https://www.asdk12.org/lottery.

There are several school types on this lottery, including charter schools and alternative schools. Two of the charter schools are correspondence/home schools, while the others focus on culture, a specific language, STEM (science, technology, math), or a structured basic curriculum.

Two of the most popular among the lottery schools are Aquarian Charter School and Northern Lights ABC alternative school. Students attending these schools have performed extremely well on the State’s PEAKS summative test.

A listing of the PEAKS scores (2020-21) for all the charter and alternative schools:

SCHOOL                                                           ENGLISH-LANGUAGE-ARTS/MATH / Percent advanced and proficient

Anchorage School District (All schools) – 43/37

Alaska Native Cultural Charter School – 23/16

STrEaM Charter School – 55/30

Aquarian Charter School – 73/59

Eagle Academy Charter School – 75/79

Family Partnership Charter School – 70/66

Frontier Charter School – 88/58

Highland Academy Charter School – 47/26

Northern Lights ABC School – 74/66

Polaris K12  – 54/39

Rilke Schule Charter School – 62/61

Steller Secondary School – 78/54

Winterberry Charter School – 64/17

Birchwood ABC School – 58/58

These figures indicate the percentage of students proficient in English/language arts and mathematics. 

Proficiency rates are not the only factor to consider. One must first consider what learning style/curriculum fits a child best.

There is usually a long waiting list for students to get into most of these schools. A few years ago, there were more than 2,500 students on the waiting list for these schools. The schools are in demand because they cater to the customers’ needs-the parents.

Why is there so much demand for these schools with so little supply from the ASD?  Because the district is a monopoly it does not have to respond to customers’ demands.  If a shoe store only offered brown shoes, one style and one size, it would not be in business for long. Customers would go elsewhere to buy shoes.

If the district wants a new neighborhood school, it merely floats a bond, builds the school, and bills the taxpayers. On the other hand, if parents want a charter school, they must organize, develop a long business plan, and then get approval from the local school board. This usually takes more than a year. 

The greatest hurdle for a new charter school is finding a facility to house the new school. In the Anchorage School District, even though there are some schools with less than 60% fill rate, schools will not be consolidated to free up a facility for a charter school. 

Parents/guardians must also consider that they must provide transportation for their children, even though the district receives transportation funding for that child. Unfortunately, this can deter low-income and single parents from even applying for a charter/alternative school.

It’s common for parents to be overwhelmed by the procedures and hurdles one must go through to win this lottery, but winning a spot could be the best thing that happens to your child.  

The district is holding an event to learn about its charter and alternative schools on Saturday, Feb. 19 from noon to 4pm at the ASD headquarters, 5530 East Northern Lights Blvd.  Find a charter/alternative school that fits your child.  Then apply for the lottery.

Report: Anchorage students making little progress in math

11

BY DAVID BOYLE

Superintendent Deena Bishop tried to put a happy face on her report this week when she briefed the Anchorage School Board on math proficiency of students in grades three through nine.

But the results were disappointing at best, with little progress shown when it comes to student math scores.

Currently, only 37% of students in grades 3-9 in Anchorage are proficient in math according to the most recent PEAKS assessment. 

The district established a goal to have 55% of these grade 3-9 students proficient as measured by the state’s summative assessment—PEAKS by May 2026. If the target is met, 45% of this cohort of Anchorage students will be unable to do math problems at grade level by the end of school year 2026.  

The district’s goal is to have only half the students proficient in math by Spring 2022.  While achievable, it is a low target. Yet the district hopes for a massive 40% increase in math skills in the next two years (from 50% to 70%).

Between last school year and this school year the district hopes for just a 1.5% increase in student math proficiency. 

Note the decrease in math proficiency from the 2016-17 school year to the 2020-21 school year. Anchorage students saw a nearly 10-percentage point drop—a 17% overall drop.  

The district puts some of the blame for low math performance on the various student demographics — race, low income, homelessness, and special education. Still, white students and wealthy students were only about 73% proficient in math.

There is a “bright spot” in the ASD: According to a strategic planning document presented to the board on Jan. 6, 2020, “The overall graduation rate is a bright spot for ASD which is at an all-time historical high of 84%”.  

In other words, not even half of the students are proficient in math, yet they are being graduated out.

Looking back, PEAKS results for 2019 showed that 46% of third graders and 30% of ninth graders achieved ‘proficient” or higher scores on the PEAKS math assessment. What is happening to a student between the 3rd grade and 9th grade?  Here is the chart from January 2020 school board retreat:

In the chart above, students from all races actually became less math proficient between grade 3 and grade 9. 

In the past few years, the ASD has changed it math program from EveryDayMath (EDM) to GoMath to the current I-Ready Math.  The EDM program was a failure because it was too conceptual for most students and did not focus on foundational math concepts. 

This district considered several programs to replace EDM. One of these was Saxon Math.  However, Saxon Math was discarded early on.  But this math program seems to work very well in schools where it is being used:

SCHOOL  / PEAKS (Percent of students proficient and above)

ASD (overall) – 37%

Aquarian Charter School – 59%

Eagle Academy Charter School – 79%

Northern Lights ABC School  – 66%

Birchwood ABC School  – 58%

The numbers point to the curriculum as a cause of the poor math proficiency in the district.If a student does not have a good grasp of math basics, that student will have a difficult time in algebra and higher math.

A second cause of low student math proficiency may be the lack of effective classroom instruction. Bishop addressed this in her briefing but noted that it is still “a work in progress.”  There are no data provided regarding the effectiveness of classroom teachers, and “work in progress” is not particularly measurable.

The district does admit that increasing math proficiency requires effective instruction in the classroom. But it has not identified gaps and barriers to identify lower performing teachers and support for those teachers. 

The formula for excellent education is an effective classroom teacher, a motivated student, and an excellent curriculum.