Sunday, July 27, 2025
Home Blog Page 1413

Sen. Donny Olson criticizes Nome police?

ARRESTED WOMAN LATER ATTENDED AND SPOKE WITHOUT INCIDENT AT GOVERNOR’S MEETING

Sen. Donny Olson took a stand against Nome Police today, after they handcuffed a woman who approached and yelled at Gov. Michael Dunleavy as he arrived at the Nome Airport, on his way to giving a budget presentation.

Brenda Evak was arrested at the airport by the local force for disorderly conduct, prompting Olson, a Democrat from nearby Golovin, to issue the following statement from Juneau, on the State of Alaska Senate Democrats letterhead:

“This afternoon, I was notified that Nome resident Brenda Evak was arrested today for using her First Amendment rights to voice her concerns to Governor Dunleavy at the Nome airport,” Olson said in a statement.

“All Alaskans and Americans have the right to free speech. It is outrageous that an Alaskan expressing an opinion to the Governor is treated this way. Alaskans are angry, and they feel like their voice is not heard. I hope Governor Dunleavy takes the experience from this event to understand the impact his budget is having on all Alaskans and uses it to finally start governing this state on behalf of its people,” Olson said, evidently not in command of all the facts surrounding the incident, including the inconvenient truth that his own local police force were in charge.

It’s unclear why Nome police arrested Evak, who was shouting loudly but who had not made any apparent threats. State Troopers were not involved in the decision.

The governor then held a meeting at a local church, gave his presentation on the budget, and opened it up to questions. About 15 people from the audience spoke, a mix of some who support him and others who criticized his budget.

Among those attending were a number of his former students who came to Nome to see him, and the quiet majority of people who attended the meeting supported his approach to fiscal responsibility.

Evak, who was wearing a Defend the Sacred sweatshirt, was released by police and attended the meeting, where Gov. Dunleavy welcomed her to speak.

Evak’s question to him was, “How much money have you been paid by the Koch Brothers?”

The answer he gave was that the Koch Brothers had not paid him anything.

There was clearly organized opposition at the meeting, but the governor made sure everyone who raised their hand had a chance to speak.

Black Rifles Matter: Human Rights Commission to meet in executive session

27

PERSONNEL ‘MATTER’

The Alaska Human Rights Commission has an executive session meeting scheduled for Monday, April 1 to take up the matter of its top manager: Can Marti Buscaglia be salvaged or has she so damaged the reputation of the commission that she must be shown the door?

Buscaglia, the executive director of the Commission, earlier this month instructed a state worker to put a note on a contractor’s truck, telling him to get out of the parking lot with his offensive “Black Rifles Matter” truck decal. She thought it was racist. She thought it was “hate speech.”

The truck belonged to a local plumbing company that was doing work on the downtown building where the Human Rights Commission has its offices.

The commission has a reputation for investigating hardworking business owners for all kinds of infractions, such as firing people wrongly or not allowing service animals on premises. The businesses often have to pay fines to a charity, such as an animal shelter, as part of their penance.

But by putting a note on the back of her business card telling the contractor to remove his vehicle,  Buscaglia took her authority a step further.: She may have violated the constitutional rights of the plumber who owns the truck.

She also took her vengeance to Facebook, mocking the owner of the vehicle for his decal, all under the name of the Human Rights Commission, and the State of Alaska seal.

The plumber went on social media to describe what happened. Read Must Read Alaska reports on the incident here:

[Read: Human Rights director thought she was regulating ‘hate speech’]

[Read: Human Rights Commission vs. First, Second Amendment]

Gov. Michael Dunleavy asked the Department of Law to conduct an investigation, and that investigation has been wrapped up and delivered to the Commission’s volunteer board, whose chairman is Brandon H. Nakasato.

The “personnel matter” on the calendar could mean Buscaglia’s possible removal. She is not a classified employee and can be dismissed by the commission for cause.

Protesters notwithstanding…

THE SHOW MUST GO ON: BUDGET DIALOGUE AT 49TH STREET BREWERY

As expected, about 300 pro-tax, anti-Permanent Fund dividend Alaskans chanted and ranted, grandstanded and reprimanded the governor of Alaska outside the 49th Street Brewery in Anchorage on Tuesday evening. It was a beautiful evening for a protest.

Inside a full house of other Alaskans, a notably older crowd, was politely listening to Gov. Michael Dunleavy and his team describe the Dunleavy fiscal plan, how the state came to run out of cash, and why such drastic budget cut measures are needed now.

 

The Dunleavy team — including the governor, OMB Director Donna Arduin, Attorney General Kevin Clarkson, Revenue Commissioner Bruce Tangeman — gathered on the stage and went through a program that had a series of slides full of charts and diagrams.

Dunleavy started at the beginning of the oil boom, when Alaska was rolling in money and spent it like there was no tomorrow. But the spending really got going once the price of oil spiked in 2006. But the prices started crashing in 2013.

 

Commissioner Tangeman was up next, and he laid out the alternatives — Alaska can drain the Permanent Fund Earnings Reserve Account, enact taxes and cut the Permanent Fund dividend, or cut spending, essentially back to 2006 levels.

Attorney General Clarkson detailed the three constitutional amendments that the Administration says will help stabilize Alaska going forward by protecting the dividend from future political raids, prevent an income tax without a vote of the people, and put a cap on state spending. The Administration wants Alaskans to vote on all three.

BOTTOM LINE

For many years after oil was flowing through the pipeline, Alaska’s budget stayed remarkably stable, with about a 2.5 percent growth per year. Then, in about 2006, the budget increased by 15 percent.

If Alaska lawmakers had kept the level of annual spending increases to 2.5 percent instead of the spike, Alaska would have $130 billion in the Permanent Fund now, instead of the $65 billion it actually has, and it would be generating more than $6 billion a year for state services — plenty to do the job.

Instead, the state plowed through $29 billion, as lawmakers started to horse trade away Alaska’s future in exchange for special spending in their home districts.

DECIDE FOR YOURSELF: WATCH THE PRESENTATION

Outside, protesters were having none of it. They’d made up their minds. Led by Anchorage Assembly member Forrest Dunbar, they chanted and clapped as instructed: “Save our Ferries. Clap. Clap. Clap-Clap. Clap”

Some banged on the door of the brewery to upset the proceedings inside, and a couple of protesters burst into the room and unfurled a “RECALL DUNLEAVY” banner. Dunleavy gave them a nonchalant look as they were ushered out.

Although it’s not clear the protesters outside learned anything from the presentation other than some old Berkeley protest chants from the 1960s, they can still watch it at the Anchorage Daily News’ live feed here.

Today, the governor is heading to Nome, where he will continue explaining his plan to those who are interested in listening. The 4:30 pm event is free and open to the public but registration is required and seating is limited. Register here.

Tick tock: Did you file for your Permanent Fund dividend?

2

DEADLINE APPROACHES SUNDAY

As of Wednesday morning, 515,850 people had filed for a 2019 Permanent Fund dividend — that’s roughly 70 percent of Alaska’s total population of  737,438.

Last year’s dividend — $1,600 — was paid in early October to about 640,000 Alaskans — women, men, and children.

The deadline for applications is 11:59 pm, Sunday, March 31. If you’re filing online, you’ll need to have received a confirmation number for your online application in order by then; the number is generated automatically as soon as you complete it and hit the submit button.

To file in person, Permanent Fund office locations in Fairbanks, Anchorage, and Juneau are open until 4 pm through Friday. They’ll be open Saturday in Anchorage and Fairbanks from 10-2 pm. In Juneau, the office will be closed on Saturday, but staff will accept applications in the large meeting room at the Mendenhall Public Library.

THE ENVELOPE, PLEASE

How much will qualified Alaskans receive this year?

That’s a political decision being debated by lawmakers and the governor. Gov. Michael Dunleavy ran his campaign on a few themes. Among them was returning to the original formula that was used to establish what Alaskans receive as their share of oil royalties. The formula was ignored by Gov. Bill Walker.

Twenty-five percent of all bonuses and royalties from oil development are required by statute to be deposited into the Alaska Permanent Fund.

Of that 25 percent, 50 percent of the realized earnings were historically issued to Alaskans as dividends in this “owner state.”

Walker set the amount for this year’s check at $1,800 in his proposed 2020 budget.

But then Dunleavy won office. By his calculation — the historic formula — it’s closer to $3,000.

The Alaska Legislature has 60 different ideas of what it should be, and may set it below $1,000 in order to hold government spending static.

It’s all up in the air, having been made a political decision, rather than a formula decision, by the Walker Administration. Every time a Finance subcommittee meets in the House of Representatives, the Permanent Fund dividend gets smaller, as lawmakers carve out more money for programs.

Dunleavy also has filed legislation to return to Alaskans the portion of their dividends that the state kept from them in 2016, 2017, and 2018.

According to the historic formula, eligible Alaskans should have received $3,678 additional dollars during those three years. The funds – $2.3 billion in money that didn’t go into Alaskans’ pockets – sits in the Earnings Reserve Account of the Permanent Fund.

The historic formula is. one thing. The Percent of Market Value of 5.25 percent draw is also the law. The two laws working together mean $2.9 billion is set aside —  $1.9 for dividends and $1 billion for government.

Under Dunleavy’s plan, the people of Alaska would get it paid back to them over three years. Here’s how the Dunleavy Administration plans to pay it back:

2016:

Dividend Paid = $1,022

Historic Calculation = $2,083

Unpaid Dividend = $1,061

2017:

Dividend Paid = $1,100

Historic Calculation = $2,389

Unpaid Dividend = $1,289

2018:

Dividend Paid = $1,600

Historic Calculation = $2,928

Unpaid Dividend = $1,328

Total Unpaid Dividends for 2016, 2017, 2018 = $3,678

“As Alaska’s Governor, I believe the historic PFD program represents a share of our natural resource wealth. It allows every Alaskan to share in our natural resource wealth, which ultimately belongs to the people, and ensures that government is accountable to the people,” Dunleavy wrote in a letter to Alaskans that is posted on the Permanent Fund Division’s website.

“The PFD delivers a resource efficiently to the people, bypassing government agencies, and allowing each of us to decide how best to spend it. The PFD is equitable since it compensates everyone equally, even future generations, regardless of who’s in power or their political opinions,” he wrote.

Under Dunleavy’s payback plan, SB 23 and SB 24, Alaskans who received a dividend in 2016 and are eligible for this year’s dividend will get an extra $1,061 this year. If they received one in 2017 and are eligible for one next year, they’ll get another $1,289, and for those who received one in 2018 and are eligible in 2021, the amount is an additional $1,328.

The dividend reductions in 2016 and 2017 are in still in the Earnings Reserve Account. But the 2018 reduction of of the dividend has been spent on this year’s budget.

Whatever the amount is, it gets paid in October. Eligible Alaskans can apply here.

No deal: Murkowski, Sullivan vote against ‘Green New Deal’

12

U.S. Senators Lisa Murkowski and Dan Sullivan today voted against what they described as costly and impractical “Green New Deal,” a resolution introduced in the House by Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), and in the Senate by Senator Ed Markey (D-MA).

Murkowski, who chairs the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee and serves on the Appropriations Committee, spoke on the Senate floor in advance of the vote, turning her remarks toward the more practical, pragmatic steps Congress can take to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

Murkowski emphasized areas where Congress has made progress in supporting policies to reduce emissions: increased funding for the research and development of clean technologies, expanding the tax credit for carbon capture, utilization, and sequestration, and passage of bills to promote more emissions-free hydropower and nuclear energy.

She called for reducing domestic and global emissions by developing clean resources, including renewables, and announced plans to introduce a bipartisan bill for advanced nuclear reactor concepts.

Murkowski asked her fellow lawmakers to commit to bipartisan solutions that support innovation and promote efficiency.

“The only way we are going to be moving is if we move together,” she said. “That’s what we’ve got to do here in Congress. We’ve got to take these policies that can keep us moving to lower emissions, to address the reality of climate change, to do so all the while that we are recognizing that we’ve got an economy that we need to keep strong, that we have vulnerable people that we need to protect, that we have an environment that we all care about—Republicans and Democrats. And it’s not just the environment in our states or our country, but it’s our global environment. How we’re working forward, together, is a priority— or should be a priority for us all. My hope is we get beyond the rhetoric, the high-fired rhetoric and we get to practical, pragmatic, bipartisan solutions.”

Sullivan linked the health of Alaskans to the responsible resource development in their state.

“As Alaskans can attest, there is a strong correlation between poverty, the lack of economic opportunity, and the health of our citizens,” said Senator Sullivan. “Responsible resource development historically has lifted whole communities out of poverty and lengthened life expectancy.

“I cannot support a proposal that would place such an absurdly large tax burden on American taxpayers and, at the same time, seek to vanquish whole industries that so many Alaskans and Americans rely on to support their families. I thank my colleagues who had the courage today to show where they stand on this truly radical effort to upend our country and its economy,” he said.

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell called the resolution up for a vote today, and it failed 0-57. Forty-three senators in the Democratic minority, including the dozen senators who originally co-sponsored the resolution, voted “present,” rather than giving the resolution any credence.

University president: Resign ourselves to economic recession?

It’s not clear if University of Alaska President Jim Johnsen was engaging in irony, has simply resigned himself to a bleak future for the state … Or it there’s simply a typo in the university’s transcription of Johnsen’s 2019 State of the University address this afternoon at the Wood Center Ballroom on the Fairbanks campus?

The entire address can be watched at this link.

The way the tweet reads, Johnsen appears to have decided Alaska should just accept losing population and an extended economic recession. The transcript has yet to be posted, so perhaps his message was lost in translation because it received a standing ovation, according to UA’s Twitter feed.

Johnsen’s message was generally upbeat and inspirational, and he lifted up the university’s research programs as world class, particularly in the area of Arctic research.

He admitted that the loss of accreditation of the teacher licensure programs at UAA “is most certainly a failure.” Johnsen said the Board of Regents will decide on April 8 whether to seek accreditation for those UAA programs.

Facing a budget cut from the State of Alaska that is 17 percent of the University System’s entire budget, Johnsen used the opportunity to make the case that the university is a good investment.

The proposed cut is $134 million, he said “or 41 percent of our state funding of $327 on top of state funding cuts four out of the last five years. These cuts hurt UA and they harm Alaska’s ability to grow the highly trained workforce we need to be economically competitive.”

House fails to override Trump veto on wall

8

REP. DON YOUNG VOTES TO SUPPORT PRESIDENT

The U.S. House of Representatives has failed to override President Donald Trump’s veto of a Democrat-led attempt to block his declaration of a national emergency on the border with Mexico.

The House needed 290 votes, but mustered only 248 in its effort block Trump’s veto of House Joint Resolution 46. Trump declared a national emergency on February 15, to direct funds to build a wall along the southern border. He used the authority of the National Emergencies Act; presidents have used the act nearly 60 times since it was enacted in 1976.

Alaska Congressman Don Young voted along with the majority of Republicans to support the president. Twelve Republicans voted with the Democrat majority.

The failure to override the veto allows the president to access up to $3.6 billion in military construction funds.

Congress has already appropriated substantial funding in past legislation — legislation that was supported by Democrats who today want to prevent Trump from fulfilling one of his main campaign promises.

More than 76,000 illegal immigrants were apprehended or deemed inadmissible at the southern border in February, according to the White House, which pointed to an “unprecedented surge in the number of alien families arriving at the southern border – more than 40,000 arrived last month.”

The president noted that apprehension of illegal immigrant families has spiked by 300 percent compared to the same period last year, and this has put a strain on resources at the border.

“As alien families arrive in record numbers, loopholes force the Government to release many of them into the interior, after which they often fail to appear in court. Large migrant groups are streaming to our border, with 70 groups of 100 or more migrants attempting to cross this year. By comparison, only 13 such groups attempted to cross last year,” the White House said.

The southern border is the primary highway for drugs such as cocaine, hero, methamphetamine and fentanyl. In the past two years, Immigration and Customs Enforcement has arrested 266,000 illegal immigrants with criminal records and deported 5,872 known or suspected gang members.

.

Now it’s Dunleavy’s turn

9

TAKING IT TO THE PUBLIC SQUARE THIS WEEK

The weekend belonged to the House Majority, with hearings around the state on the governor’s proposed budget.

This week belongs to the actual fiscal plan to bring the state budget in line with actual revenues, and to close the $1.6 billion gap this year. The governor is out and about, with a heavy schedule of appearances on the budget and the three constitutional amendments he wants to send to voters — amendments he says will stabilize things going forward:  locking in the Permanent Fund dividend formula so it’s no longer politicized, putting in place a spending cap, and making any income tax subject to a vote of the people.

On Must Read Alaska’s Facebook page on Monday, over 1,100 people took part in 23-hour poll on the budget.

The result? 93 percent of respondents said they leaned toward budget cuts rather than an income tax and reduced Permanent Fund dividend.

As with the House Finance Committee hearings and the governor’s forums this week, a Facebook poll is self-selecting and not representative of the public at large.

House hearings have leaned heavily toward income taxes and reduced dividends, except in the Mat-Su Valley, which supported a reduced budget. In other areas of the state, union members and teachers dominated the testimony.

[Read: Mat-Su testifies: Cut the budget]

[Read: Juneau spoke: Tax us, cut our PFD]

TO THE PEOPLE

Gov. Michael Dunleavy is taking the unusual step of taking his case to the people during the legislative session, when normally governors tend to let the Legislature have the spotlight.

But this year is like no other. This governor wants to roll back spending. Under four years of Gov. Bill Walker, the State has gone through $14 billion in savings to hold government services at levels the state could not actually afford. Walker added more than 40,000 Alaskans to the Medicaid rolls and hired climate change experts and “change agents.” He cut Alaskans’ dividends.

This week, the Dunleavy budget, his 10-year fiscal plan, and three alternatives that the governor is using for comparison, will be vetted.

Governor Dunleavy has proposed a budget based on five core tenets:

  • Expenditures cannot exceed existing revenues
  • Focus on core functions that impact most Alaskans;
  • Maintain and protect our financial reserves;
  • Minimize the financial burden on Alaskan families; and
  • The budget must be sustainable, predictable, and affordable.

“This plan presents a vision of a smaller State government, with more money in the pockets of Alaskans, planting the seeds for economic growth and providing higher levels of freedom and individual liberty. This is accomplished by reducing State spending and making statutory and constitutional adjustments to prevent future excessive growth in government spending at the expense of the people,” the plan says.

[Read: The Dunleavy 10-year fiscal plan and alternate scenarios]

Dunleavy started in Kenai, with a forum that included his budget director, commissioner of Revenue and others in his cabinet. He was applauded as he walked into the room at the Cannery Lodge. A few protesters were outside, and a few were inside, but they were respectful. Everywhere he goes people are giving him red pens, to indicate their hopes for vetoes of the House budget.

Today, the governor heads to Anchorage, where he’ll face heavy union resistance at his evening forum at the 49th State Brewery.

GOVERNOR’S APPEARANCE SCHEDULE

March 26 – Anchorage

Associated General Contractors

10am – 11am: Talk of Alaska with Lori Townsend – Alaska Public Media Network
More Information

Alaska Support Industry Alliance – Anchorage Chapter Event

4pm: The Dave Stieren Show – KFQD
Listen Live

5pm: The Mike Porcaro Show – 650 KENI
Listen Live

6pm – 8pm: 49th State Brewing Company (Free and open to the public event with AFP-Alaska and Alaska Policy Forum)
Register Online *

March 27 – Nome

4:30pm – 6:30pm: Old St. Joe’s Civic Center (Free and open to the public event with AFP-Alaska and Alaska Policy Forum)
Register Online *

March 28 – Fairbanks  

8am – 9am: Carlson Center – Greater Fairbanks Chamber of Commerce “Understanding Alaska’s Fiscal Situation”
More information **

6pm – 8pm: Westmark Hotel (Free and open to the public event with AFP-Alaska and Alaska Policy Forum)
Register Online *

March 29 – Fairbanks & Mat-Su

7am – 8am: Alaska Miners Association

6pm – 8pm:  Everett’s Mat-Su Resort (Free and open to the public event with AFP-Alaska and Alaska Policy Forum)
Register Online *

According to those traveling with him, Dunleavy is getting great response, with people shouting “Stand strong, Mike!” as he passes through airports and before he goes into interviews and meetings. And then there’s this thing with the red pens — he’s being given them wherever he goes.

That’s not the message that came through during the House Finance Committee hearings, however.

House Majority members have made it clear that they do not intend to pass the governor’s budget, but are eventually going to offer some version of former Gov. Bill Walker’s budget to the Senate.

But so far, the only plan on the table is the Dunleavy plan, and it would impact all Alaskans because it calls for a huge chunk out of spending on everything from education to Medicaid to public broadcasting.

House Speaker Bryce Edgmon summed up his opposition while on KTOO last week, saying that he doesn’t understand why Dunleavy keeps talking about his budget, since Edgmon doesn’t like it.

“The governor’s emphasis … continues to be on large reductions and on a full PFD, as well as backfilling the PFDs, which, you know, I don’t think that’s where the Legislature is in terms of making decisions on the upcoming budget,” he told KTOO.

PROTESTERS EXPECTED

Protesters are expected in the Anchorage meeting this evening. The AFL-CIO received a quickly granted parade permit and has several special interest groups joining union members in what is predicted to be a rowdy and disruptive gathering outside the forum at the 49th Street Brewery. Security will probably be heightened inside the building as threats have been made on Facebook.

Breaking: Sturgeon wins Supreme Court, 9-0 on river access

ANILCA RULES THE DAY IN FAVOR OF ACCESS

Hunter John Sturgeon has been battling for 12 years and has spent $1.2 million to defend Alaskans’ rights to use their rivers as highways. He’s been to the Supreme Court, and won a partial victory two years ago.

But the court asked the Ninth Circuit to review its work, and the Ninth again ruled against the moose hunter who had been stopped by Park Service rangers on the Nation River, and was sent packing.

Today the U.S. Supreme Court, in a unanimous ruling of 9-0,  ruled that the Nation River is not “public” land, (this means it is not federal land) and like all non-federal land is navigable inside of Alaska’s national parks. It’s Alaska land.

Rivers are exempt, the court ruled, under the Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act, from the National Park Service’s ordinary regulatory authority. The Park Service doesn’t get to order Alaskans off of rivers in the state.

Justice Kagan wrote the opinion and Justice Sotomayor filed a concurring opinion, joined by Justice Ginsburg, three of the most liberal judges on the Supreme Court.

“What it says is that Alaska not only owns the rivers, but it gets to manage the navigable rivers in the state. Alaska is different. The Supreme Court has said it again and again, that we are different, not only by culture, but by law,” said Sturgeon. We should be treated differently — that’s what the law said.”

Sturgeon said he had many people to thank, and that is was not a win just for his right to hunt, but for all Alaskans.

“It’s a huge win for all of Alaska. People congratulate me, but hundreds of people helped me in this lawsuit — people like Craig Compeau of Fairbanks and Ed Rasmuson, who have been my two biggest supporters from the beginning. But people have helped, from $5 to $20,000, and the Alaska Outdoor Council added $100,000.”

[Read: John Sturgeon, hunter, heading back to Supreme Court]

[Read: Sturgeon gets round two at Supreme Court]

About 8,000 cases were denied by the U.S. Supreme Court this session, but Alaska’s John Sturgeon vs. Frost (U.S. Park Service case #17-949) was accepted — for the second time.

The high court’s first ruling in favor of Sturgeon in 2016 was narrow. It sent key questions back to the Ninth Circuit, which doubled down  in October, 2017 on its ruling against state sovereignty and aspects of the Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act. The 9th Circuit judges ruled the federal government has authority over rivers within the national parks under a broad scope of water reservation provisions in federal law.

That left Sturgeon going back to the Supreme Court, which issued its ruling this morning, 12 years after Sturgeon was stopped by Park Service rangers while navigating the Nations River on his way to his moose hunting grounds.

Justice Kagan wrote:

“Petitioner John Sturgeon traveled for decades by hovercraft up a stretch of the Nation River that lies within the boundaries of the Yukon-Charley Preserve, a conservation system unit in Alaska. On one such trip, Park rangers informed him that the Service’s rules prohibit operating a hovercraft on navigable waters ‘located within [a park’s] boundaries.'”

“Sturgeon complied with the order, but shortly thereafter sought an injunction that would allow him to resume using his hovercraft on his accustomed route. The District Court and the Ninth Circuit denied him relief, interpreting Section 103(c) to limit only the Service’s authority to impose Alaska-specific regulations on inholdings—not its authority to enforce nationwide regulations like the hovercraft rule.

[Read the entire ruling here]

“Today’s ruling represents an important moment for Alaska’s sovereignty and the rule of law,” said Gov. Michael Dunleavy. “Once again, the Supreme Court shows why the Ninth Circuit Court is one of the most out of touch and out of line courts in the nation.”