Breaking: Sturgeon case gets round two at Supreme Court - Must Read Alaska
Connect with:
Thursday, September 19, 2019
HomeThe 907Breaking: Sturgeon case gets round two at Supreme Court

Breaking: Sturgeon case gets round two at Supreme Court

About 8,000 cases were denied by the U.S. Supreme Court this session, but Alaska’s John Sturgeon vs. Frost (U.S. Park Service case #17-949) was accepted — for the second time. The announcement came this morning.

JOHN STURGEON DECISION

The high court’s first ruling in 2016 was narrow, but in Sturgeon’s favor. It sent key questions back to the Ninth Circuit, which doubled down  in October, 2017 on its ruling against state sovereignty and aspects of the Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act. The 9th Circuit judges ruled the federal government has authority over rivers within the national parks under a broad scope of water reservation provisions in federal law.

The Supreme Court accepts fewer than 1 percent of the cases brought to it. But after the court took his case the first time in 2016, Sturgeon felt somewhat more confident it would accept his case again, if only because the 9th Circuit simply ignored the Supreme Court’s directions for review.

“Going to the Supreme Court is a miracle,” said Sturgeon. “And of the 8,000 petitions this term, they took 20. It means that hopefully the federal government will understand the state sovereignty issues: The State of Alaska owns the rivers and navigable waters, and it gets to manage them, under the provisions of ANILCA. Above all, this is about state sovereignty.”

Read the October, 2017 story on this Alaska case at Must Read Alaska.

WHAT HAPPENS NEXT

Sturgeon thinks the case will be heard this summer, and that the justices will answer the question of whether Section 103c of ANILCA says the federal government cannot control navigable waters and has no control over inholdings on national parks and preserves under ANILCA.

Donations Welcome

Share

Written by

Suzanne Downing had careers in business and journalism before serving as the Director of Faith and Community-based Initiatives for Florida Gov. Jeb Bush and returning to Alaska to serve as speechwriter for Gov. Sean Parnell. Born on the Oregon coast, she moved to Alaska in 1969.

Latest comments

  • Great news! Although the journey is still underway, hope to retain state sovereignty and access rights is revived. 1 of 20 cases to be heard out of 8000 petitions – so awesome Alaska beat the odds! Thanks to John Sturgeon for his persistence in pushing back against federal overreach. I stand with you, John. Your battle impacts us all. So glad the Ninth Circuit doesn’t get the final word on this. Suzanne, I shared your article on about 20 pages.

  • The Supreme Court only hears cases from October-end of June. Mr. Sturgeon’s case won’t be heard by the Court this summer. Likely, it will be heard December/January.

  • Regardless of when it is heard, this step is Three-fold blessing: John Sturgeon is fighting for us, bless him; the 9th Circuit court ignored the Supreme Court directives, shame for again ignoring the Constitution and the Bill of Rights; the Supreme Court seems to be heading back to the Constitution. Prayers are being answered!

%d bloggers like this: