The disservice of silence: Christians in the public square post-midterms

0

Following the recent election, withdrawal from the public realm can seem tempting, but it is not an option. This is not the moment to retreat into private silence. It is the moment to begin speaking with one another again—carefully, charitably, and with clarity—about the things that matter most.

For as long as I can remember, many adults have repeated the counsel: “Never talk politics or religion at family gatherings or in public.” Whoever first popularized that advice did us all a great disservice. The intention may have been to keep the peace, but the effect was to empty the one place where these conversations most needed to happen: the kitchen and dining-room table. When families stopped discussing the moral foundations of life, education, justice, and the common good for fear of discord, they did not create neutrality. They created a vacuum, and schools, universities, media, and cultural institutions stepped in to fill it. They have used that opening to reshape not only the day-to-day dynamics of our country but its long-term trajectory. What began as an attempt to avoid conflict became an invitation for others to form the next generation without the counterweight of family conversation rooted in faith and reason. St. Thomas Aquinas, the Angelic Doctor, would not call this habit prudence. He would recognize a disordered fear, a vice opposed to fortitude because it shrinks from what reason requires us to endure for the sake of the good (Aquinas, ca. 1265–1274/1947, II-II, q. 125, aa. 1–2).

We are obliged to engage in politics above all when the dignity of the human person and the salvation of souls are at stake, and the recent election makes clear that we are living in such a time. Human dignity is under pressure at nearly every level: legal, cultural, educational, and economic. When the conditions of family life, education, religious freedom, and the protection of the vulnerable are contested, silence is not neutrality. It is a choice with consequences.

Aquinas teaches that conscience is not a feeling or a private preference. It is an act of the practical intellect—the application of what we know to what we do (Aquinas, ca. 1265–1274/1947, I, q. 79, a. 13). The Church, building on his teaching, defines conscience as a judgment of reason by which the person recognizes the moral quality of a concrete act, and she insists that conscience must be informed and moral judgment enlightened (Catechism of the Catholic Church [CCC], 2000, paras. 1778, 1783). Aquinas adds a sobering point: even an erring conscience binds, yet when the error is culpable it does not excuse (Aquinas, ca. 1265–1274/1947, I-II, q. 19, aa. 5–6). That is why formation matters so much. Without a well-formed conscience shaped by reason, the natural law, and the truths of faith, we cannot reliably distinguish right from wrong or act in a way that truly serves human flourishing and eternal life. An unformed or malformed conscience leaves us vulnerable to whatever ideology dominates the culture, and it can lead us to do wrong while feeling entirely right.

The Church has long warned against the ideologies that most directly threaten this dignity. In Divini Redemptoris (1937), Pope Pius XI condemned atheistic communism as “intrinsically wrong,” noting that it denies God, undermines the family, and treats the person as a mere instrument of the collective (Pius XI, 1937, paras. 9–11, 58). Earlier, in Quadragesimo Anno (1931), he had rejected the core errors of socialism, teaching that its conception of society is foreign to Christian truth and that “no one can be at the same time a good Catholic and a true socialist” (Pius XI, 1931, paras. 117, 120). The Catechism states plainly that the Church has rejected the totalitarian and atheistic ideologies associated in modern times with communism and socialism; the same paragraph also refuses the individualism of a capitalism that places the law of the marketplace above human labor (CCC, 2000, para. 2425). The Church’s judgment is not a party platform. These ideologies, whatever their rhetoric of equality or freedom, consistently subordinate the person, the family, and religious liberty to the state, the party, or the market.

At the same time, the Church insists that Catholics are not excused from civic life. Gaudium et Spes teaches that the political community exists to serve the common good and that citizens have both the right and the duty to vote freely to promote it (Second Vatican Council, 1965, paras. 74–75). Christifideles Laici and the Catechism call the lay faithful to take an active part in public life (John Paul II, 1988, para. 42; CCC, 2000, paras. 1913–1917), and the Catechism names voting as a moral obligation flowing from our shared responsibility for the common good (CCC, 2000, para. 2240). Good citizenship is never optional, and it becomes urgent when the foundations of justice and the conditions for living the faith are under pressure. Voting, informed discussion, local involvement, and the defense of the vulnerable are ordinary expressions of this responsibility. That responsibility begins at home, around the tables where the next generation first learns what is true, what is worth protecting, and why it matters.

This does not mean turning every family dinner into a political rally. It does mean refusing the false peace of silence when essential truths are at stake. Speak with charity, but speak. Form consciences—beginning with our own—through prayer, study of the Church’s social teaching, and honest conversation at the table. Engage the public square not as partisans first, but as people who recognize that the dignity of every human person and the possibility of salvation are not private hobbies. They are the reasons we have a public life at all.

The election has clarified the moment. The response is not retreat. It is renewed speech, better-formed consciences, and a deliberate re-entry into the responsibilities of citizenship. This begins at the kitchen table, where the trajectory of the country is still being decided.

Primary Sources

Aquinas, T. (1947). Summa theologica (Fathers of the English Dominican Province, Trans.). Benziger Bros. (Original work written ca. 1265–1274)

Catechism of the Catholic Church (2nd ed.). (2000). Libreria Editrice Vaticana; United States Conference of Catholic Bishops.

John Paul II. (1988). Christifideles laici [Post-synodal apostolic exhortation]. Libreria Editrice Vaticana. https://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/apost_exhortations/documents/hf_jp-ii_exh_30121988_christifideles-laici.html

Pius XI. (1931). Quadragesimo anno [Encyclical letter]. Libreria Editrice Vaticana. https://www.vatican.va/content/pius-xi/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xi_enc_19310515_quadragesimo-anno.html

Pius XI. (1937). Divini redemptoris [Encyclical letter]. Libreria Editrice Vaticana. https://www.vatican.va/content/pius-xi/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xi_enc_19370319_divini-redemptoris.html

Second Vatican Council. (1965). Gaudium et spes [Pastoral constitution on the Church in the modern world]. Libreria Editrice Vaticana. https://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_const_19651207_gaudium-et-spes_en.html