Tuesday, April 21, 2026
Home Blog Page 1183

Ghosts of Christmas past

5

By WIN GRUENING

“It is a fair, even-handed, noble adjustment of things, that while there is infection in disease and sorrow, there is nothing in the world so irresistibly contagious as laughter and good humour.”
― 
Charles Dickens, A Christmas Carol

While our country, along with the rest of the world, struggles with the challenge of defeating a pandemic that has taken countless lives, devastated economies, and put millions out of work, there is now cause for optimism.  A life-saving vaccine produced in record time gives hope and a reason to celebrate this Christmas. 

This isn’t the first time the world has faced similar hardships and did so with far less scientific knowledge and medical expertise. 

Plagued by financial problems in 1843, Charles Dickens wrote A Christmas Carol out of necessity, completing it in just six weeks, just in time for Christmas. 

A Christmas Carol has become one of the Western world’s most beloved holiday stories. It has been translated into several languages and been adapted many times for film, stage, and opera, and most recently by Juneau’s own Perseverance Theater in an indigenous adaptation, A Tlingit Christmas Carol.

75 years later, the 1918 flu pandemic, also known as the Spanish flu, swept the world in a series of waves and infected 500 million people – a third of the world’s population at the time. The death toll has been estimated to have been somewhere between 17 million and 50 million, and possibly as high as 100 million, making it one of the deadliest pandemics in human history.

Much like today, quarantine rules were established, large gatherings were discouraged, social distancing and masking were often required.  Most schools across the country closed.  Complicating the response to this pandemic were the necessary logistics of fighting a war in Europe where pandemic precautions were often impractical.

Because Alaska was remote and sparsely populated, the Spanish flu arrived later in the Territory than in other areas of the U.S. The first cases in Alaska struck in October of 1918.

According to an Alaska Department of Health and Social Services study, 1,113 influenza deaths occurred during the 2-year pandemic period, 962 in 1918, and 151 in 1919.  The monthly number of deaths peaked at 831 just before Christmas, 1918.

With Alaska’s  population at approximately 58,000 in 1917, this was an extraordinarily high number of deaths. Extrapolating the 1918-1919 death rate calculations on the state’s 2016 population indicate a similar pandemic would have resulted in almost 14,000 deaths in Alaska today.

Unlike the current pandemic, the largest proportion of influenza deaths were in persons aged 30 to 44 years (30%), followed by those aged 0 to 14 years (24%).  The vast majority (81.7%) of deaths were Alaska Natives, mostly from the Nome area.

In Southeast Alaska, 76 flu deaths were recorded, a little under half of those from Juneau.  Higher deaths were recorded in the Anchorage/Matsu area and SW Alaska and Gulf Coast communities.  

Local newspapers in Juneau and the neighboring town of Douglas reported on the pandemic but did so with restraint.  Home study school assignments were published in the newspaper each week. Editorial comment suggested tongue-in-cheek that masks “…give that added touch of mystery that is so appealing to the average person.”

The day after Christmas, 1918, with 70 patients hospitalized, The Daily Alaska Empire reported “a very quiet Christmas for all Douglas Island residents yesterday. Owing to quarantine regulations, no Christmas parties or Christmas tree festivities were in evidence. The mail boat was in, however, and there was plenty of good cheer, Christmas packages and word from the loved ones at home.” 

Just one year later, Christmas Eve, 1919, the same newspaper reported the following: “Juneau fairly pulsated today with the holiday Christmas spirit, which will be the culmination of several days of shopping tomorrow. Starting this evening, Christmas tree entertainments will be held nearly every evening.”

A century ago, despite the challenges, it seems Alaskans weathered the historic pandemic with good humor and resolve.

As Alaskans now embark on the New Year approaching, a positive attitude and willingness to help our neighbors will speed our recovery.

And as Dickens’ character, Tiny Tim, famously said, “God bless us, every one!”

Win Gruening retired as the senior vice president in charge of business banking for Key Bank in 2012. He was born and raised in Juneau and graduated from the U.S. Air Force Academy in 1970.

A day to celebrate

Merry Christmas from Must Read Alaska.

A special thanks to all of our doctors, nurses, medical teams, researchers, and first responders. Thank you for working on Christmas Eve and Christmas Day.

Also, Merry Christmas and thank you to our military members and veterans, especially those who are serving far from their families today. May God keep you safe and may your day be gentle. If you are serving in Alaska and your family is in the Lower 48, know that we appreciate having you here, and we honor your service.

And to all the others who rise today and put on their winter gear to go out and keep our roads cleared, our lights on, and our oil fields running, we’re thinking of you today, too. We tip our hat to our other frontline workers — those who keep our supply lines open and keep our grocery shelves stocked.

Today I’ll mostly take the day off to celebrate the birth of Jesus of Nazareth, a poor Galilean born in Bethlehem around the time of King Herod’s death. He, a carpenter, teacher, and Savior, walked a path unlike any before him or since. A life worth celebrating, and a Savior worth following.

May your road be well-sanded, with no icy spots today and no standing moose, may your heart be warm, and may the Christmas spirit live within you throughout the rest of the year.

Love and Peace,

Suzanne

Merry Christmas: Fish and Game posts new species update on Santa’s reindeer

2

Just in time for the big ride, the Alaska Department of Fish and Game has posted a biological report on Santa’s reindeer on its animal profile web page. Included is a photograph of Rudolph and his red nose.

According to the report, “Santa’s reindeer (R.t. saintnicolas magicalus) look very similar to common reindeer or caribou, but have many characteristics that distinguish them from the seven other common subspecies. In Europe, caribou are called reindeer, but in Alaska and Canada only the semi-domesticated form is called reindeer.

“All caribou and reindeer throughout the world are considered to be the same species, and, including Santa’s reindeer (R.t. saintnicolas magicalus), there are 8 subspecies: barrenground (Rangifer tarandus granti), Svalbard (R.t platyrhynchus), European (R.t. tarandus), Finnish forest reindeer (R.t. fennicus), Greenland (R.t. groenlandicus), woodland (R.t. caribou) and Peary (R.t. pearyi). Alaska has mostly the barren-ground subspecies and one small herd of woodland caribou. Canada has three subspecies, the Peary, woodland and barren-ground.”

Who knew?

As for the reindeers’ usual diet, the department says “Santa’s reindeer eat the leaves of willows, sedges, flowering tundra plants, and mushrooms during the summer. They switch to lichens (reindeer moss), dried sedges (grass-like plants), and small shrubs (like blueberry) in September. An interesting question is how such foraging behavior is possible at the North Pole, an icy region in which plant life can’t be said to prosper. But then again, Santa’s house is not an ordinary place.”

“The diet of Santa’s reindeer during the month of December consists almost entirely of carrot snacks. This enables them to fly long distances, during short periods of time, in unfavorable visibility conditions.”

Carrots, people. Santa’s reindeer love Alaska carrots.

The migration patterns of Santa’s reindeer are the subject of scientific differences, the department reports. Whether the annual night flight of R.t. saintnicolas magicalus may technically be considered a migration is debated in scientific circles. Further, the reindeer won’t be wearing masks as they circle the globe because they are immune from the coronavirus.

“Though there are very few Santa’s reindeer, they are not listed as threatened or endangered. This is due to their unusual life expectancy, which is infinite,” the profile says.

Must Read Alaska sources say Santa has begun his trek around the globe and is expected back in Alaska after midnight. The weather across Alaska is Christmassy, at 36 degrees in Ketchikan, and -1 degree in Utqiagvik.

More fascinating details about Santa’s reindeer ecology from the jolly ol’ biologists at Fish and Game are found at the department’s species profile catalog at this link.

Study: Alaskans are highly compliant with mask recommendations

A new poll shows that the vast majority of Alaskans are abiding by either local mandates or state recommendation to wear a face mask over nose and mouth when in public, to ward off the highly infectious COVID-19 virus.

Anchorage, Seward, and Juneau have mask mandates, while most of the rest of the state is going by recommendations, rather than mandates. Several large stores like Fred Meyer and Carr’s have their own mask requirements.

According to the statewide public opinion poll conducted over the Thanksgiving holidays, more than eight in 10 Alaskans report wearing a face mask “some or all of the time.” Also, 82 percent believe it’s important to change their daily habits to prevent the transmission of the virus.

But only 75 percent of Alaskans who responded to the survey think masks actually work to prevent the spread of the virus that came from China late last year. One out of four Alaskans do not think the masks work as promised by medical experts.

According to scientists, COVID-19 is transmitted from human to human, and can spread rapidly through a population that is in close proximity to others. One contagious person can infect hundreds of people without knowing it. Hand-washing, disinfecting touch surfaces, and physical distancing from others are three methods for slowing down the spread. Masking is another method widely touted.

A separate multi-university study of behaviors shows that nationally, the first three components of preventative actions — hand washing, disinfecting, and avoiding crowds — reached an all-time low in October. But mask wearing was increasing, and by November, 77 percent of respondents were reporting they adhere to the mask recommendations.

Read the study here.

Alaskans exceed that masking compliance level, yet Democrats in the Legislature and in local governments have repeatedly demanded that masks be mandated on a statewide level by the governor because Alaskans are not to be trusted to follow the health recommendations.

The Alaska governor’s approach has been to treat Alaskans like grownups, explain to them the importance of precautions, and encourage them to do the right thing.

California’s governor, on the other hand, has numerous mandates in place, but doesn’t enforce them. Instead, the California government is forcing businesses, such as restaurant workers and store clerks, to enforce the state’s mask mandates, turning shopkeepers into mask police and pitting customer against store employees.

In the Alaska study, conducted by Dittman Research, 67 percent of respondents also said they trust the advice of state health officials.

That leaves a gap of one third of the public that is not trusting the official state advice. However, about the same number — 65 percent of Alaskans — are limiting their social interactions due to COVID-19. When the vaccine is available to them, 64 percent say they plan to get it.

The national survey points out the partisan divide on behaviors:

Democrats and Republicans have both tended to increase mask wearing and decrease social distancing during this study period, which began in the spring. The gap between Democrats and Republicans when it came to wearing masks was 16 points in the spring, but had increased to 20 points in November.

While the national study reflect a partisan divide and sorting among gender, race, and education, the age of survey participants yielded some thought-provoking results. While younger people tend to be more Democratic, they had lower ‘social distancing” scores. Younger Democrats, it seem believe that masks will protect them even if they go to crowded places.

If the State of Alaska study has breakdowns by demographics and partisan preferences, it did not release those tabs to the public.

In other survey news, USA Today released a poll on Christmas Eve showing that more than 37 percent of all Americans don’t believe Joe Biden was legitimately elected.

The breakdown was 78 percent of Republicans, 3 percent of Democrats, and 32 percent of Independents who do not believe the election result is legitimate.

The poll of 1,000 registered voters Dec. 16-20 show that 57 percent of Republicans don’t think Trump should concede the election.

AIDEA board votes to bid on ANWR Coastal Plain leases

36

With environmental groups threatening companies that may have sought to bid on leases in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, Alaska’s own economic development corporation has decided to make sure those leases get buyers.

The board of the Alaska Industrial Development and Export Authority on Wednesday unanimously voted to allow the agency to bid up to $20 million on leases in the 1002 Area of the Coastal Plain of ANWR. The agency could then partner with a company to do the actual development work.

The federal lease takes place on Jan. 6, and some have worried that threats by environmentalists and fearful banks, that are responding to intense environmental pressure, will suppress interest in the opportunity to develop oil in the extremely resource-rich area.

Environmental groups and some private companies are threatening economic sanctions against companies that dare to work in the Arctic. Recently, The North Face refused to sell jackets to an oil services company, following in the footsteps of Patagonia; both companies make jackets, tents, and backpacks out of oil.

This fall, the Wilderness Society penned a letter to the CEOs of Chevron, ConocoPhillips, ExxonMobil, and Hilcorp, warning them off of bidding on the leases. The letter, signed by 250 environmental organizations and some businesses, demanded the companies refuse to bid and also make a “public statement in opposition to the development of oil and gas in the Arctic Refuge. The reputational, environmental, climate and economic risks of drilling in the refuge are not worth the potential harm such calamity can do to your brand.”

The threatening letter continued:

“Investors are also taking notice. As evidenced by the recent announcements from five of the six largest US domestic banks, the pursuit of oil and gas development in the Arctic Refuge comes with tremendous financial risk as well. Soon we will also be briefing asset managers, insurance and reinsurance companies on the risks of doing business in the Arctic Refuge. As the global community works to pivot away from fossil fuels in the face of climate change, the pursuit of oil and gas in remote corners of the globe will continue to face strong social and political opposition.

“Pursuing oil and gas in the Arctic Refuge is increasingly fraught with financial risk. At a time when demand for oil and gas is likely in permanent decline, drilling in the Arctic Refuge doesn’t make fiscal sense. Arctic lease sales are likely to be challenged legally, resulting in additional costs for your beleaguered industry. The risks of investing in new oil exploration are high – no investment in drilling in the Arctic Refuge should be considered safe.”

Wednesday night’s meeting of the AIDEA board was dominated by members of environmental groups testifying in opposition to the proposal, with caribou, polar bears, and other wildlife being their chief concern. Polar bears are now relatively abundant in the Arctic, with their main threat being Native and their Inuit-guided trophy hunting clients, which are responsible for about 900 polar bear deaths each year. There are believed to be more than 31,000 polar bears in the Arctic, a dramatic increase from the 12,000 polar bear count in the 1960s. Likewise, caribou are abundant, particularly in the North American Arctic.

The AIDEA board discussed the leasing proposal in executive session for over two hours and then voted unanimously to proceed.

It’s the latest salvo in the war over Alaska’s future economic viability as a state, and a 352,00-acre portion of the refuge’s 1.6 million acre coastal plain, which is mainly gravel and water.

Earlier this month, environmental groups and their surrogates asked a federal judge in Anchorage to prevent the U.S. Department of Interior from allowing the leases to proceed before President Donald Trump leaves office. Inauguration Day is on Jan. 20, 12 days after the lease sale is scheduled.

In all, four lawsuits have been filed since August over the lease sales, with three of them asking for preliminary injunctions.

Acting mayor backs out of buying America’s Best Inn for homeless, but Aviator Hotel is filling the gap

32

The acting mayor of Anchorage says the city will not buy America’s Best Value Inn as part of an overall plan to address the need for additional shelter and housing caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. 

Acting Mayor Austin Quinn-Davidson had already backed out of purchasing the Tudor Road Alaska Club building to provide services to vagrants and homeless in Anchorage.

But Quinn-Davidson did go ahead with the purchase of the Golden Lion Hotel on 36th and New Seward earlier this month, a purchase that came in at over $9 million.

The Golden Lion, Alaska Club, and America’s Best Value were part of a four-building purchase authorization by the Municipal Assembly to spread services and shelters throughout various districts in Anchorage, and take the burden off of the urban core, where most of the social problems related to homelessness and drug or alcohol addiction are centered.

But meanwhile, 120 homeless people are being housed at former Mayor Mark Begich’s Aviator Hotel on 4th Avenue in downtown Anchorage. Begich acquired the sprawling building earlier this year. Without customers, Begich cut a deal with the city to house homeless, at a rate not yet revealed by the municipality.

The highly controversial Ordinance 2020-66 authorized the purchase of specific buildings as part of former Mayor Ethan Berkowitz’ plan to expand the homeless industrial complex in Anchorage.

After he resigned in disgrace, Acting Mayor Quinn-Davidson inherited the project, which she had approved as part of the Anchorage Assembly, which directed some of the CARES Act funds from the federal government for the ambitious project.

The America’s Best Value Inn on Spenard Road backs up to a dormitory-style building that houses youth from villages who come into Anchorage for training. As it turns out, like the Tudor Road building, repairs would cost too much.

“Through the due diligence process, which the MOA uses before acquiring any property, significant costly repairs and mandatory upgrades were identified, including extensive upgrades to the elevators, stairwells, plumbing and electrical systems, and repairs to the exterior siding and roof. While some mandatory upgrades and repairs were anticipated, the costs of these upgrades and repairs were so high as to make acquisition no longer in the best interest of the municipality,” the acting mayor wrote.

“COVID-19 created an acute shortage of shelter space in Anchorage. The Municipality addressed the problem by standing up the mass shelter at the Sullivan Arena, however, that is not a permanent solution. The Sullivan Arena was not designed or intended to function as a shelter, and operating it as one costs almost $1 million per month. This cost is temporarily being reimbursed by the Federal Emergency Management Agency. Providing more housing options will return the Sullivan Arena to general community use, save the Municipality money, and help reduce homelessness in Anchorage, ensuring residents aren’t left out in the cold,” she wrote.

“The Anchorage Assembly previously directed the MOA to create additional shelter space, supportive housing, and support services outside of the downtown area; the MOA will continue vetting properties that meet that criteria,” she wrote.

Slippery slope of government schools as family substitute

48

By TIM BARTO

At a recent Kenai School Board meeting, and as reported in Must Read Alaska,  an impassioned argument was made to get young students back into the classroom.  

By all accounts, the individual making the argument holds solid conservative credentials, but part of his statement belies a belief that government can best provide love and care to children.  

To be fair, the argument was not made that this was true of all teachers or all children, but it in his righteous zeal, the speaker allowed that the government – in this case, public school teachers – provides the most positive thing some kids get in their daily lives.  

This is not just a slippery slope towards big government, it is a tumble down the slope that is sure to be greeted by the wide and welcoming arms of the nanny state.  

Collective theory wants us to believe it is government, not family, that is best suited to make our lives better, more complete.  It is, in fact, the type of thinking upon which collective theory depends.    

It brings to mind a scene in The Killing Fields, a 1984 movie that revealed the atrocities committed in Cambodia by the Khmer Rouge, in which a group of children are being indoctrinated in the ways of the party.  A young student is called to the blackboard to demonstrate what actions were needed to make the party and the state the ultimate providers to the children.  

On the blackboard was a stick figure drawing of a family; a father and mother and their three children, all lined up with outstretched hands joining them. The student placed a large X through the parental figures, then physically erased the spot in which the mother’s hand grasped the eldest child’s hand.  

The goal was clear: the collective would nurture the children and attend to their needs. Parents were not needed in the Khmer Rouge family.  

Government entities should never be seen as the best providers of love and care for anyone. That is the responsibility of individuals and families.  While it may, in fact and with great misfortune, be true that some kids get better treatment in school than they do at home, it should not be seen as an argument for getting the whole lot of them back into brick and mortar buildings.

Schools exist to educate, and that is what the focus should be:  quality education, not surrogate parenting.  According to the latest National Assessment of Educational Progress scores, Alaska’s fourth graders are dead last in the country in reading ability.  With results like that, the focus has to be on learning, not simply getting kids back into their government-supplied seats. 

Admittedly, schools provide positive benefits such as socialization, athletics, structure, and mentorship, but those are by-products.  The main product should always be quality education. 

Tim Barto is the father of five Alaska-born and homeschooled children.

Judge reverses dismissal of Rep. Lance Pruitt lawsuit against Elections Division

26

Anchorage Superior Court Judge Josie Garton today reversed her ruling of Tuesday, when she had dismissed a claim by Rep. Lance Pruitt that a last-minute change of polling places in his district had an impact on election results.

In today’s surprise ruling, Garton stayed her previous dismissal. Evidently, after Tuesday’s testimony, the judge believes that there’s enough smoke, and there may very well be fire.

Pruitt lost by 11 votes to Liz Snyder when the election was certified. But the polling place that has always been strong for him was moved with no notice, and that worked against Pruitt.

On Tuesday, his lawyer Stacey Stone showed the court that the last-minute change of voting venue confused voters and likely depressed the turnout on Election Day.

Stone had brought political analyst and election expert Randy Ruedrich, a Republican campaign volunteer, to explain how a drop in at least 57 votes in the district was enough to have given Snyder the win.

That’s because Snyder and the Democrats did not turn out at the polls on Election Day. Their strategy all along was to get everyone on their side of the political aisle to vote absentee.

Today, when called to the witness stand, Dr. Snyder fudged the truth, telling the court that she didn’t even know the polling place had been moved until she learned of the lawsuit by Pruitt.

But lawyer Stone then presented the court an exhibit that showed that on Nov. 3 — Election Day — Snyder had written on Facebook that the polling places were wrong at the Division of Elections website.

When shown the exhibit, Snyder said that one of her campaign staff must have posted it, not her. She sought to put distance between herself and her Facebook page, disavowing the words under her image.

Lawyer Stone also quickly took apart the state’s key witness, an economist at the Institute for Social and Economic Research at the University of Alaska.

On behalf of the State, Democrat Ralph Townsend proceeded to explain why he thought Ruedrich’s analysis of Tuesday was wrong.

Stone quickly neutered his testimony, as he admitted he had no experience analyzing elections or performing election data analysis. He did, however, take a few political science classes as an undergraduate, he offered. Townsend is a fisheries expert.

Townsend was discredited as a witness after, at the beginning of his testimony, he said he volunteered to be an expert witness, only to later admit to the court that he had been recruited to testify by Liz Snyder’s lawyer, Jennifer Alexander who also slipped him the Ruedrich written analysis to take a look at. It was not yet a public record.

Another one of the Snyder witness was dismissed by the judge. Snyder’s proposed witness was going to walk the court through how to use the “Way-back Machine” on the internet. The judge ruled the man was not an appropriate witness. The Wayback Machine is a simple internet archive of websites.

No more witnesses were called by the Snyder-State side of the election case today. Closing arguments, due Thursday, will be done in writing.

Judge Garton could rule or proceed to a “fact and findings” for the Supreme Court to take up the matter.

Legislature to sue Dunleavy after legislators did not vote on his appointees

24

The Alaska Legislative Council is suing Gov. Mike Dunleavy over appointments of numerous public servants, who the Legislature has not confirmed. The appointees were not confirmed because the Legislature refused to call itself into session after gaveling out in May, with its constitutionally mandated work unfinished.

The confirmations of tens of dozens of appointees — from Revenue Commissioner Lucinda Mahoney to members of the Fish Board and Oil and Gas Commission, and even Public Defender Samantha Cherot — were left hanging after the Legislature gaveled out of session earlier this year in a desperate attempt to get out of Juneau ahead of the COVID-19 virus.

 The Legislature suspended its regular session effective March 29 through May 18, 2020. The Legislature then adjourned on May 20.

Lawmakers, in what some see as a failure of the leadership of Sen. President Cathy Giessel and House Speaker Bryce Edgmon, never reconvened in special session to finish their work.

The Legislative Council, which manages the affairs of the Legislature when it is not in session, met in executive session on Tuesday before voting 11-1 to sue the governor.

Sen. John Coghill, of Fairbanks, made the motion to sue the governor and was supported by Sens. Tom Begich, Natasha Von Imhof, Cathy Giessel, Lyman Hoffman, Gary Stevens, and Reps. Neal Foster, Jennifer Johnston, Chuck Kopp, Louise Stutes, and Steve Thompson. Sen. Bert Stedman voted no. Von Imhof was not present.

Dunleavy has said in various statements to the media that his appointees would continue to serve, but House Rep. Chuck Kopp, who lost his reelection bid and who is a foe of the governor, calls the governor’s action unlawful “according to HB 309.”

HB 309 was actually signed into law by Dunleavy, apparently to make a good-faith gesture toward the Legislature, which was not finishing its work in the spring. The bill says the any of his appointees who are not confirmed by the Legislature will expire before the next legislative session.

Now, the governor says that as far as he is concerned, those appointments are valid because the Legislature failed to fulfill its constitutional duty.

HB 309 may in fact be in conflict with the Alaska Constitution, which says the Legislature “shall” meet to confirm the governor’s appointees.

HB 309 may have allowed hostile members of the Legislature such as Kopp, who serves as House Rules Chair, to perform a “pocket veto,” a term used to describe killing legislation or an action by simply putting it in one’s pocket. That method of chicanery was something to be avoided in the Alaska Constitution, which set up a form of government that allows the governor to nimbly execute the laws of the state. The Legislature is under a constitutional mandate to perform this duty, but it also cannot be sued if it does not perform it.