Tuesday, August 5, 2025
Home Blog Page 1482

Walker claims Republicans begged him to run

During the Resource Development Council gubernatorial debate in Anchorage today, Gov. Bill Walker made the alarming claim that the Alaska Republican Party reached out to him and asked him to be its candidate for governor.

He made the assertion in response to a question from Mike Dunleavy, the Republican nominee for governor. Dunleavy had asked him to explain all of his backroom plots and plans with Democrat candidate Mark Begich.

Walker responded by saying that the Alaska Republican Party had contacted him after Mark Begich had filed for governor in the Democrats’ primary, where Walker had already announced he was running. Walker quickly ejected himself from that primary and went directly to the General Election as a petition candidate.

Republican Party Chairman Tuckerman Babcock scoffed at the governor’s assertion and suggested the governor was either overtired or joking — or was losing his grip on reality.

“Governor Walker needs a nap and an iced tea,” Babcock said. “The only official or unofficial contact regarding Bill Walker running as a Republican came from Scott Kendall (the governor’s chief of staff) on behalf of the governor to ARP leaders. Our response to Mr. Kendall’s inquiry was that it was a free country and Bill Walker could run as a Republican if he wanted to. We predicted the reception would not be warm. All of those inquiries from the governor occurred prior to the convention of the Alaska Republican Party, held in Anchorage last March.”

Reporters swarmed the governor after the debate to ask him more questions about the resignation of former Lt. Gov. Byron Mallott. One reporter asked Walker if he meant what he said about the Republican request that he run, and he doubled down on the assertion.

“The governor has switched his party, his program, and his running mate so often that we believe he has lost track of the truth,” Babcock said.

Kawasaki has boundary confusion

0

THE SOUTHERN REACHES OF FAIRBANKS?

Rep. Scott Kawasaki, the Fairbanks Democrat who is running for Senate Seat A against incumbent Sen. Pete Kelly, has gotten it in his head that the Fairbanks Senate district stretches all the way to Palmer, Alaska, 330 miles to the south.

Kawasaki sent a long letter on his State Legislative letterhead to Richard Best, who was a candidate for local assembly in Palmer, congratulating on his win, telling him how important Best’s work for Fairbanks is, and saying how he looks forward to working with Assemblyman Best for all of Fairbanks.

Best was mystified. Not only is his local senator Shelley Hughes, but he lost his campaign for local assembly to Pete LaFrance.

 

Unions have emergency meeting in Anchorage

13

PROMETHEUS. REALLY?

Alaska’s biggest union bosses have called an emergency meeting in Anchorage today to discuss the mess they have with the governor’s race.

They’ve spent hundreds of thousands of dollars attacking gubernatorial candidate Mike Dunleavy and supporting Gov. Bill Walker, only to find Walker’s campaign in a complete tailspin.

Lt. Gov. Byron Mallott set off the crisis by resigning in disgrace on Tuesday.

[Read: Plot thickens on Mallott resignation]

The Walker-Mallott ticket was the one unions created in 2014, when AFL-CIO boss Vince Beltrami told Bill Walker and Byron Mallott that unions wouldn’t support either of them, but only support them if they combined their tickets.

The two did as they were told and went on to victory against the incumbent governor, Sean Parnell.

Now, in 2018, Unite Alaska for Walker-Mallott’s top contributors include Robin Brena, the Sealaska Corporation (where Byron Mallott’s son is CEO), and labor unions.

With Mark Begich ascending and Walker in crisis, what do the unions do?

Do they stick with Walker and his new Acting Lieutenant Governor Val Davidson? Or do they jump to Begich?

“The unions are going to stab Walker in the back,” said Tuckerman Babcock, chairman of the Alaska Republican Party. “Vince Beltrami is a fair-weather friend and in his lust for power he’ll sacrifice just about anything or anyone.”

At this point, Walker has a tough time pulling out of the race, since the ballots are printed. Even if he pulls out, he’ll get 15 percent of the vote, simply because his name is on the ballot.

But the union-backed Unite Alaska for Walker-Mallott has been working on a huge smear campaign on Dunleavy. The unions have to decide now if they want to smear Dunleavy on behalf of Walker or pull their support and do so on behalf of Begich.

The union’s smear campaign is looking like it is on increasingly shaky grounds, something Beltrami cooked up months ago. The details of their smear campaign have been leaked along with the word “Prometheus,” which is the apparent code name he has devised.

Meanwhile, the Walker-Davidson campaign has cancelled its booth at the Alaska Federation of Natives and has refocused a major fundraiser planned for tonight. It is now just a reception.

“Join the Walker team at the Downtown Anchorage Historic Hotel for a Walker informational reception. We have taken down the fundraising component for this event, but the Governor and Lt. Gov. Val Davidson, and our team, will be here to answer questions and listen. We will continue to show up and be here for Alaska,” his campaign wrote.

Polling shows Begich and Walker about even with each taking 25 percent of the vote as of last week.

The plot thickens on Mallott resignation

A WOMAN’S REVENGE

Even an ill-advised remark to a 16-year-old doesn’t normally get a statewide elected official pressured out of office two days later. After all, comments between men and pretty girls have been happening since the dawn of time.

And a lovers’ quarrel between “close associates” normally wouldn’t get a lieutenant governor in the political crosshairs either, unless it came to blows.

But if a lieutenant governor makes an inappropriate overture to the daughter of his “close associate,” that’s another matter altogether.

It was not a private altercation between Lt. Gov. Byron Mallott and an unnamed middle aged woman at the Elders and Youth Conference. It was at least a little bit public. The situation became known, and that information made its way back to the governor’s chief of staff.

The young girl’s mother evidently had a close relationship with Mallott, who is 75. Must Read Alaska has learned that Mallott said something to the daughter — and the mother went ballistic.

On Tuesday, Mallott was no longer welcome at the Alaska Federation of Natives. He is one of the founders of the organization. Mallott left AFN and went back to Juneau immediately. He resigned from office and apologized to the person he made inappropriate comments to:

Gov. Bill Walker appointed Lt. Gov. Valerie Davidson in his place on Tuesday afternoon but clammed up about the reason his running mate and one of his best friends in the world had suddenly resigned.

[Read: Breaking: Lt. Gov. Mallott resigns]

Gov. Bill Walker, right, and Lt. Gov. Byron Mallott

Just weeks before Mallott’s career came to a screeching halt, Walker and Mallott had penned a statement to Sens. Lisa Murkowski and Dan Sullivan, objecting to the confirmation of Brett Kavanaugh to the U.S, Supreme Court, noting that with the sexual assault allegation against Kavanaugh, they couldn’t condone his confirmation “while so many questions remain unanswered.”

This week, however, it was Mallott caught in the snare of his own making.

Democratic gubernatorial nominee Mark Begich issued a statement today: “Like so many Alaskans, I was shocked and saddened to hear the news about Lt. Governor Mallott. While many questions have yet to be answered, I believe accepting the Lt. Governor’s resignation and replacing him were the appropriate course of action. There must be a zero tolerance policy for inappropriate behavior of any kind from our elected leaders. Faith in government is essential to public trust and moving Alaska forward. That is why I continue to believe that Alaska’s best future can only be built by bringing together all Alaskans.”

Gov. Bill Walker is still not describing the nature of the behavior that forced the lieutenant governor out of office. Gov. Walker’s communication staff said that more information would be released as soon as they can do so.

Whenever that is.

VALERIE DAVIDSON IS ACTING LG

According to Alaska State Statute, an appointment of the lieutenant governor is subject to the confirmation by the majority of the members of the Legislature meeting in joint session. The governor swore Valerie Davidson in on Tuesday in a secret ceremony.

In addition, the governor needs to appoint the next in line for succession, but has not announced who he has chosen.

At this stage, Valerie Davidson is an acting lieutenant governor until the Legislature convenes on Jan. 15 or until a new governor is sworn in on Dec. 3.

Davidson will be the keynote speaker at the Alaska Federation of Natives conference on Thursday.

What did Mallott do that was so bad?

0

GOVERNOR’S EXPLANATION LEAVES QUESTIONS

The Governor’s Office has clammed up about what Lt. Gov. Byron Mallott did and when he did it.

But the rumors are flying: It happened at AFN Elders and Youth Conference. No, it happened at Tanana Chiefs Conference, and the person is in law enforcement. No, it was that Mallott told First Lady Donna Walker to go “F–” herself. No, it’s back to AFN and Mallott propositioned an underage girl, “If you were a bit older and I wasn’t married …

They are rumors, they are all over the map, but none of them explain to the public why Mallott was forced to sign a letter of resignation — clearly a letter that he did not write himself.

The governor does not have the power to fire the lieutenant governor. However, he does have the ability to blackmail him.

Bromance: In campaign photos and in official photos, Gov. Bill Walker and former Lt. Gov. Byron Mallott were inseparable.

Mallott’s adversary Mark Begich also has the means and motive to blackmail him. The Mallott-Begich relationship can be described as tense, if not hostile. Bad blood exists between those two.

A man like Mallott, full of Tlingit pride and an elder in the Native community, just doesn’t humiliate himself like this and sign a letter of contrition for an “inappropriate” remark to a 17-year-old.

WHO REPORTS TO WHOM?

The public is the entity to which Mallott reports, and the public is not being told why their lieutenant governor cleaned out his desk and was gone in a flash.

The public has a right to know, but the Governor’s Office is treating the matter as though Mallott was an employee of the governor, not the public.

The three rules of crisis communication are that you are first, you are right, and you are credible. At this point, the Governor’s Office has not met the minimum requirement of any of these rules. The explanations offered have instead appeared politically motivated.

The official story has also morphed. Here’s a timeline of what we’ve been told:

Sunday: Something happens. Lt. Gov. Byron Mallott does something wrong. The Governor’s Office is not saying more.

Monday: Gov. Bill Walker is made aware by his Chief of Staff Scott Kendall on Monday afternoon that Lt. Gov. Byron Mallott had made “inappropriate comments” to a woman.

Monday night: Walker and Mallott discuss the matter on Monday night.

Tuesday morning: Walker and Mallott continue their discussion.

Tuesday 11:30 am: The governor heads to Anchorage Downtown Rotary to debate Mike Dunleavy and Mark Begich. He angrily lashes out at Dunleavy and at one point challenges him to a one-on-one debate, which Dunleavy accepts in concept. The debate ends and Walker huddles with his wife Donna, his daughter Lindsay, and his campaign manager John-Henry Heckendorn in a corner of the Dena’ina Center, talking intensely.

Tuesday early afternoon: Gov. Walker heads to the Atwood Building, goes to the 17th floor, and swears in Valerie Davidson as lieutenant governor — in secret. It is not known at this time when he accepted the letter of resignation from Byron Mallott.

Tuesday mid-afternoon: Walker assembles a press conference and says that he had sworn in Davidson “this morning or early afternoon.” Walker makes a brief statement. Davidson makes a brief statement. The two depart the conference room without taking questions. They leave Austin Baird, their press secretary, and Grace Jang, deputy press secretary to romance the media, since both of them have close relationships with the press. Chief of Staff Scott Kendall is nowhere to be seen in any of these proceedings.

Austin Baird, the governor’s press secretary, tells the press corps that they’ll have more information later. Reporters badger him for information.

Grace Jang explains the governor learned of the events “late” Monday night, and says the lieutenant governor takes full responsibility.

Baird and Jang provide photos of the swearing in of Davidson and a copy of the resignation letter during the press announcement, but do not post the video of the historic events.

The Governor’s Office later furthers the explanation saying that the behavior involved an inappropriate “overture.”

Will Begich play second fiddle in ‘New Mystery’ ticket?

12

TALKS UNDERWAY TO COMBINE WALKER-BEGICH

The campaign manager for the Bill Walker for Governor camp has publicly confirmed that talks have been underway between Walker and Mark Begich, the Democratic nominee for governor.

Now that Byron Mallott is out of the way on Walker’s ticket, that leaves an opening for Walker to fill. Although Valerie Davidson was sworn in as lieutenant governor for now, Walker has no path to re-election at this point, and he knows it. There is no poll on earth that shows him winning in a three-way race. He needs Begich.

The two of them could then unleash the hounds of Hell on Republican nominee Mike Dunleavy. The distasteful smear they have prepared for Dunleavy will be unlike anything ever seen in Alaska politics. But they still cannot win in a three-way.

The backroom deal that Walker and Begich are trying to cut without Alaskans’ knowledge is almost exactly what happened in 2014, and Alaska ended up with the worst four years in Alaska history and Mallott resigning in disgrace. This underscores why the people should decide these things at the ballot box, and not allow politicians to rig elections in secret.

What’s in it for Mark Begich? His political future. The former U.S. senator didn’t get the traction he thought he’d get when he filed for governor in June, and he doesn’t have enough money to run a legitimate campaign. He’s likely to come in a distant third place and that would dash his political hopes for several years to come, if not permanently.

Begich’s only possible play is to form a ticket with Walker and be the lieutenant governor nominee on a new ticket.

AFL-CIO President Vince Beltrami, who has millions of dollars at stake and his own reputation as a kingmaker, knows it. Walker campaign manager John-Henry Heckendorn knows it.

But does Begich accept it? That’s the tough nut to crack.

Begich is not a good fit for Walker. The two men do not like each other, and Begich cannot trust that if he throws his support to Walker, that Walker will make good on his word and appoint him after the election. More to the point, he cannot trust that Walker will give him a meaningful role in the adminstration should they win.

Would this new Hydra ticket pass legal muster?

With Democrat Lt. Gov. Valerie Davidson now in charge of the Division of Elections, they have a complicit operator who will step aside and allow the new ticket with less than three weeks to go. She can find a reason to demurrer to Begich.

History informs this maneuver. In 2014, the Democrats were able to convince Hollis French to drop off their ballot, even though he had been elected as the nominee for lieutenant governor. He was rewarded with a plum sinecure.

Byron Mallott dropped off the ballot as the Democratic nominee for governor and accepted the second slot on the ticket with Walker, who jettisoned his own running mate, Craig Fleener, and then gave him a four-year, high-paying job with no deliverables attached.

That ticket-mandering was challenged by the Republicans in court as a fraud on the voters, but the judge accepted it by saying, essentially, “that’s politics, get over it.”

But in 2018, the ballots have already been printed. Thousands of absentee ballots have been voted already. It will be up to Walker’s Administration, with Davidson in charge of Elections, to explain the new scheme, and will be up to Walker’s attorney general to defend it.

In this scenario, Davidson would agree to say that although she is now the lieutenant governor, she would not be the candidate on the ballot. She will provide a plausible case for why she doesn’t want to “run” for re-election after having served for just a few days.

“Under the Alaska Constitution, a vote for governor is considered a vote for the lieutenant governor running with him or her,” according to the Division of Elections.

Presumably, Walker is free to appoint Begich as his running mate for purposes of campaigning, even though Mallott’s name will still appear on the ballot.

“Even if a lieutenant governor withdraws, the gubernatorial candidate may remain on the ballot,” the division said. “Accordingly, if Governor Walker is re-elected, Byron Mallott will technically be elected along with him.”

Begich would also remain on the ballot as the Democratic nominee, even if he agrees to become the running mate to Walker.

Therefore, Walker and Begich would have to expend massive campaign funds to explain to voters that they should ignore Mallott’s name on the ballot and assume that the Lt. Governor would be Begich, and ignore Begich’s name and assume he will join Walker after the election.

The question is if someone votes for Begich, is that also a vote for Walker? If they are running mates, this is the argument they will likely make to the courts: A vote for either of them is a vote for the other.  But would the courts support this level of chicanery?

It gets even deeper. Under current state law, a vacancy in the office of Lt. Governor is filled from a cabinet commissioner who has been designated by the governor in advance as first in line for succession. That designation is subject to approval by the legislature.

Absent a court ruling that sanctioned a different path, Walker would have to appoint Begich as a commissioner after the election, get legislative approval to name him as first in line for succession to Lt. Governor, have Valerie Davidson (or Mallott since he would technically be re-elected) resign, then appoint Begich.

That convoluted path of pitfalls might be a bridge too far for Mark Begich.

SMOKE AND MIRRORS

Yet, John-Henry Heckendorn, Walker’s campaign manager, has revealed two things that are in conflict:

  1. Walker, if elected, would appoint Davidson for the four-year term.
  2. Talks are underway with Begich to do anything they can to prevent a Mike Dunleavy governorship (which can only mean one thing).

Revealingly, the Walker campaign has suspended all volunteer activities for the week.  And, Valerie Davidson is the keynote speaker for the Alaska Federation of Natives on Thursday. The clock is ticking for a decision.

Last night, the campaign headquarters for Mark Begich were dark, with no apparent activity, even though the Begich camp should be pouncing on what appears to be a #MeToo meltdown of the Walker campaign. An odd time to be idle, unless the very definition of the two tickets are in limbo.

Clearly, talks are underway in a private room, somewhere, during what has been a frustrating election season for both Walker and Begich. They are not done trying to salvage their quest for power. They both know that if they don’t find a way to agree, they are likely to go down the drain together.

The manipulation and corruption of the election process started in 2014 under the thumb of left-wing power brokers Vince Beltrami and Alice Rogoff. It may be time for Republicans to lawyer up and prepare to contact the Department of Justice to prevent voters from being disenfranchised yet again, this time in the final weeks of a major statewide election.

The very integrity of Alaska’s process for electing governors is at issue.

Lt. Gov. Valerie Davidson now runs Division of Elections

9

DETAILS EMERGE ABOUT DRAMATIC RESIGNATION OF LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR

With the sudden and unceremonious resignation of Lt. Gov. Byron Mallott today, the woman who brought Obamacare expansion to Alaska and who has overseen the collapse of the Alaska Psychiatric Institute is now running Alaska’s elections.

She also guards the State Seal and publishes regulations.

She’s now Gov. Bill Walker’s shadow running mate, although Mallott remains on the official ballot.

Valerie Davidson was one of Gov. Bill Walker’s first hires when he became governor in 2014. She has overseen the Department of Health and Social Services, including the significant cost overruns associated with Medicaid expansion in Alaska.

While Mallott is technically the running mate, he is no longer lieutenant governor. Mallott cannot remove his name from the ballot. Ballots have been printed and votes have been cast already.

This will cause some confusion among voters, and has certainly caused confusion in the Walker-Mallott campaign and the Unite Alaska for Walker-Mallott super PAC, run by Vince Beltrami and the AFL-CIO.

The AFN fundraiser scheduled for later this week for Walker-Mallott has been cancelled. Meanwhile, Davidson had already been named the keynote speaker for the Alaska Federation of Natives convention on Thursday.

While we don’t know exactly what actions occurred, the Walker Administration acknowledged there is a victim.

Sources say the victim is under the age of 18, and it’s known that Mallott was at the Elders and Youth Conference on Monday night until late last night.

The governor said he didn’t find out about the problem until later in the evening, Must Read Alaska has been told.

The Walker campaign has cancelled all campaign volunteer activities for the remainder of the week.

Walker had spent his lunch hour angrily attacking his opponent Mike Dunleavy in a Downtown Anchorage Rotary Forum. He criticized him for not attending debates and lashed out at him repeatedly.

But at the same time, Walker was sitting on a big secret that he was keeping from all Alaskans, while in a room filled with Alaska’s business community and media. Shortly after the forum, Walker returned to the Atwood Building, where he secretly swore in Davidson as lieutenant governor while accepting the resignation of Mallott.

Then he provided a minimally informational press release and then refused to answer questions from the press. This  prompted KTUU reporter Rich Mauer to tell Walker’s Press Secretary Austin Baird, “This is what the gov accuses Dunleavy of, not answering questions.”

[Read Must Read Alaska broke the news today before the governor made the announcement]

The Democrats’ nominee Mark Begich has said nothing, but Dunleavy issued a statement:

“As we, like all Alaskans, await details surrounding the resignation of the lieutenant governor, our campaign remains focused on restoring trust in state government.
“We need safe neighborhoods, a health economy and full Permanent Fund dividends. This campaign has always been about the people of Alaska, not politicians.”
The Division of Elections posted the explanation of why Mallott’s name will remain on the ballot and how it is legally possible to vote for Walker-Mallott but not end up with Walker-Mallott in office:

Breaking: Mallott forced out as lieutenant governor

Lieutenant Gov. Byron Mallott resigned today and Commissioner of Health and Social Services Valerie Davidson was sworn in as lieutenant governor. The events took place quickly in mid-day.

The announcement of Byron Mallott’s resignation was leaked before noon, but came after a secret swearing in of Davidson.

Davidson has helped lead Gov. Bill Walker’s charge in abdicating the State’s authority in favor of tribal sovereignty. And she led the charge for Obamacare Medicaid expansion in Alaska. She will now be in charge of the Division of Elections.

One decision the Walker campaign will have to make is who will be on the ticket with Walker. Mallott’s name is on the ballot now and some ballots have already been voted via absentee. Some 21,000 ballots were sent out absentee and 1,000 or more have been returned.

Intelligence that Must Read Alaska has indicates that this relates to Mallott’s behavior.

Update: Mallott is said to have made inappropriate comments to a woman.

Governor Walker and Lieutenant Governor Davidson released the following statements:

“It is with profound disappointment and sadness that I accepted the resignation of Lieutenant Governor Byron Mallott.

“Byron recently made inappropriate comments that do not reflect the sterling level of behavior required in his role as Lieutenant Governor. I learned of the incident last night. Byron has taken full responsibility for his actions and has resigned.

“As leaders, we must hold ourselves to the highest standards of conduct.

“Valerie Davidson was confirmed as Lieutenant Governor-designee earlier this April. She was sworn in today as Lieutenant Governor. Doctor Jay Butler has been appointed Commissioner of the Department of Health and Social Services. Alaskans can be confident that Valerie Davidson will assume the duties of Lieutenant Governor with grace and dignity.”

“Alaskans deserve the highest standards of conduct by their elected officials. While I am deeply saddened by the resignation of Lt. Governor Byron Mallott, I am profoundly disappointed by his conduct,” said Davidson.

“Respect for women, and the dignity of all Alaskans, is our responsibility. I stand ready to serve as your Lieutenant Governor,” Davidson said.

Mallott became lieutenant governor after he first was the Democrat nominee for governor in 2014. He stepped aside to allow Bill Walker to run in his slot, and he filled the lieutenant governor slot on the “unity ticket”. The two of them beat Sean Parnell in the General Election.

What did Lt. Gov. Mallott say and to whom? Some say it was this story:

[Must Read Alaska broke this story on Monday.]

This is the fourth Democratic forced resignation in 18 months due to misconduct involving treatment of women. The others include Representatives Dean Westlake, Zach Fansler, Justin Parish, and now Byron Mallott.

This story will be updated.

Is LGBTQ month in schools a form of month-long sex ed?

15

SOME FAIRBANKS PARENTS SAY THIS IS TOO FAR

The Fairbanks North Star Borough School Board will consider a resolution Tuesday evening (Oct. 16) that adopts November as LGBTQ month, and promotes the teaching of LGBTQ culture and history in classrooms from kindergarten through 12th grade.

Resolution 2019-08 recognizes that discrimination is bad and inclusion is good. It is being brought to the board by the district’s diversity committee.

Most of the resolution could be applied to people as a whole — all members of the education community should be valued and supported, regardless of their race, gender, or ability. In other words, be nice and don’t discriminate.

But the resolution goes a step further, to encourage the teaching of a specific kind of history — LGBTQ history and culture — throughout the month, and throughout the grades.

“WHEREAS, all students and staff members will benefit from inclusion of LGBTQ history and culture,” the resolution reads.

That “will benefit from” clause prompts teachers to include Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgendered, Queer history and culture in their classrooms.

Not all parents think that’s a benefit. Some think it’s an agenda.

The resolution promotes the contributions and accomplishments of people who have an ever-elastic gender and sexual attraction identity, and recognizes the LGBTQ community as a “growing asset.”

Some parents wonder if public schools are taking it too far. The resolution, after all, involves the teaching of human sexuality, always a controversial subject. It takes sex ed and makes it into a month-long event to normalize what some parents think is not the schools’ role, but the parents’ role.

Teachers are not forced to include these topics in their coursework, but some of them are likely to do so, bringing in drag queen story times, and special visits from LGBTQ advocates. Teachers who identify strongly with the LGBTQ movement will tend to push the boundaries from teaching respect to teaching make-up tricks.

The United Nations and Planned Parenthood have promoted curricula that reaches down as far as kindergarten to ensure that five-year-olds learn about gender fluidity. That puts schools on a collision course with parents who are teaching traditional values at home.

Elizabeth Holm, a parent from North Pole, noted that the schools are teaching that gender has nothing to do with actual biology. She encourages parents to consider opting out of school in November.

“If this is something your family is not comfortable with, Alaska Law permits parents to keep their students home the duration of the resolution but the students are still responsible for completing their homework and this does not count toward missed days, but you do need to communicate about your intentions with administration,” she wrote.

In other words this could be a perfect time to try out homeschooling, she said.