From Skagway to Springfield: Texas quorum standoff mirrors Alaska’s 1983 handcuff showdown

7

Texas House Republicans are escalating efforts to compel absent Democrats back to the Capitol, a modern-day showdown that bears striking resemblance to a dramatic political clash in Alaska more than four decades ago when Republicans disappeared from Juneau.

In Austin this week, Speaker Dustin Burrows has repeatedly gaveled in sessions without reaching the 100-member quorum required to conduct legislative business.

On Friday, the fifth consecutive day without a quorum, just 86 Republicans and nine Democrats showed up. More than 50 House Democrats fled the state Sunday in a coordinated effort to block legislative action, knowing their absence would grind the chamber to a halt.

Burrows has signed civil arrest warrants for 56 missing Democrats, and Governor Greg Abbott has threatened to have them arrested or removed from office. Abbott also petitioned the Texas Supreme Court to remove House Democratic leader Rep. Gene Wue of Houston. Lawsuits have been filed in Illinois, where many of the Democrats are believed to be hiding, asking courts to honor Texas warrants. Burrows says state authorities are working with counterparts in other states and may even have federal help in tracking the lawmakers.

It’s a rare and extraordinary measure, but not without precedent. In June 1983, Alaska made national headlines when a similar quorum fight broke out in Juneau.

That year, Democrat Gov. Bill Sheffield called a special legislative session to confirm Norm Gorsuch as attorney general. Several Republican House members, citing concerns over a perceived conflict of interest between Gorsuch and Sheffield’s hotel business, tried to block the vote by vanishing from the Capitol. On June 7, only 17 members attended, far short of the required quorum.

Some Republicans literally flew the coop, including Rep. Vernon Hurlburt, a bush pilot from Sleetmute, who rented a plane to Skagway.

https://law.resource.org/pub/us/case/reporter/F2/759/759.F2d.714.84-3626.html

Sheffield ordered Alaska State Troopers to track down missing members. The search led to dramatic scenes: Four lawmakers were found in their offices, including Rep. Ramona Barnes, smoking a cigarette, and Rep. Richard Shultz of Delta Junction, who was escorted into the House chambers in handcuffs.

In that year, the Alaska Senate included legendary members like Don Bennett, Richard Eliason, and Jalmar Kerttula, while the House featured individuals like Ramona Barnes, Ben Grussendorf, and John Sund.

The troopers’ intervention broke the stalemate, and the House ultimately confirmed Gorsuch. But the episode deepened tensions between the Republican-controlled House and the Democrat-controlled Senate, and showed just how far political leaders of that time were willing to go to secure a quorum.

Texas now finds itself in a similar high-stakes showdown, one stretching across multiple state lines, with court battles, interstate warrants, and possible federal involvement. Whether it ends like Alaska’s 1983 standoff, with reluctant lawmakers marched into the chamber under guard, is a dynamic to watch.

In other actions in the 13th Alaska Legislature, the drinking age in Alaska was raised to 21.

7 COMMENTS

  1. The interesting thing about this current flight from responsibilities is that the Democrats from Texas are upset that Republicans are attempting to undue Democratic gerrymandering and willing to face expulsion from the legislature to accomplish their goals. The manufactured and selective outrage from the left isn’t surprising so much as it is astounding. Consider the gerrymandering in just these few Democratic states New Jersey Democrats control 9 of 12 congressional seats, even though 45% of House votes go to Republicans. Illinois Democrats control 14 of 17 seats even though of House they only recieved 53% of the vote. Oregon Democrats hold 5 of 6 seats, even though 42% of House votes go to Republicans. In Massachusetts Democrats control all 9 congressional seats while Trump received nearly 37% of the Presidential votes. Look no further than our gerrymandered state legislature where Democrats have outsized influence due to rigging the lines in their favor. Americans should rightfully be concerned about the gerrymandering of elections and hold Democrats accountable for their actions of rigging elections before a single vote is cast.

      • Ralph,

        Of course you realize that the Department of Justice issued a letter that said in part
        “It is the position of this Department that several Texas Congressional Districts constitute unconstitutional racial gerrymanders, under the logic and reasoning of Petteway. Specifically, the record indicates that TX-09 and TX-18 sort Houston voters along strict racial lines to create two coalition scats, while creating TX-29, a majority Hispanic district. Additionally, TX-33 is another racially-based coalition district that resulted from a federal court order years ago, yet the Texas Legislature drew TX-33 on the same lines in the 2021 redistricting. Therefore, TX-33 remains as a coalition district.” And that is the reason for the proposed redistricting of racially based and designed Democratic districts.

  2. Redux of last week’s discussion of Jay Hammond, namely the arbitrary application of party labels mirroring one’s ideology, regardless of what published facts say. Vern Hurlbert served in the legislature as a Democrat. He was originally elected in 1978 by defeating Republican incumbent Billy Akers and reelected in 1980 over Republican Don Harris. That’s published fact as reflected in sources. On the other hand, in one of the last conversations I had with him before I left Alaska, he made it clear that he’s never been a Democrat and running as a Democrat was strictly a flag of convenience. Despite readers not paying attention last week, I’ll restate the point I made about Hammond in 1958: Bush voters have traditionally been unwilling to vote for a Republican, so why jeopardize your campaign by calling yourself one?

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.