Will Speaker Edgmon honor the signed caucus agreement on redistricting? If not, are there any consequences? - Must Read Alaska
Connect with:
Saturday, September 19, 2020
HomePoliticsWill Speaker Edgmon honor the signed caucus agreement on redistricting? If not, are there any consequences?

Will Speaker Edgmon honor the signed caucus agreement on redistricting? If not, are there any consequences?

The fix is in: The Redistricting Board that decides political boundaries and the shape of the Alaska Legislature for the next 10 years is probably going to be determined by the Democrats, because of the die cast by a handful of Republicans who made a written caucus deal with Democrats in 2019.

It all happened back on Feb. 14, 2019, when a group of House Republicans bolted from the Republican majority and formed a majority with Democrats. They were Reps. Jennifer Johnson, Chuck Kopp, Louise Stutes, Gary Knopp, Gabrielle LeDoux, Tammie Wilson, and Steve Thompson.

They put Democrat Bryce Edgmon in as speaker under the condition he would reregister as Undeclared for the length of his speakership. The leadership team involved in the coup against the Republican majority signed a document that said that Edgmon’s pick for the Redistricting Board would have to be agreed on by a majority of the Committee on Committees.

Who is on that Committee on Committees today?

Speaker Edgmon and Neal Foster, both Democrats, along with left-leaning Republicans Louise Stutes of Kodiak District 32, Jennifer Johnston of South Anchorage District 28, and Chuck Kopp of South Anchorage District 24.

Also on the committee is Steve Thompson of Fairbanks District 2, who was substituted in after former Rep. Tammie Wilson resigned from office.

Of those Republicans, only Thompson can be likely be counted on to support a conservative pick to the Redistricting Board, which by law must be seated no later than Sept. 1. Thompson faces an election opponent, but is not considered at terrible risk in his reelection campaign.

The peril for the political map is much worse when you look at the races of some of the others: Political observers say Johnston and Kopp are likely to lose their primary races to challengers James Kaufman and Tom McKay respectively.

If so, they’ll still be on the Committee on Committees until the new Legislature is seated in January, but they’ll have no motivation to protect the Republican seat on the Redistricting Board.

They could even exact revenge on the Republican Party if they lose, because at that point they would have nothing left to lose politically.

Kopp and Johnston

Also, if Johnston and Kopp lose their primaries, Edgmon will have no reason to honor his agreement with them because they will be considered “lame duck legislators.” Edgmon has no opponent in his race, and could simply appoint whomever he wants to the Redistricting Board, tearing up the binding agreement.

The makeup of the board is done through appointments: Two are seated by Gov. Mike Dunleavy, one by House Speaker Edgmon, one by Senate President Cathy Giessel, and one by Chief Justice Joel Bolger of the Supreme Court.

Senate President Cathy Giessel has developed an alliance with Speaker Edgmon.
Between them they have worked to oppose Gov. Mike Dunleavy.

The way redistricting works is that after the U.S. Census this year, political boundaries are redrawn for House and Senate districts. It’s an art and a science, and considered to be crucial in the political complexion of any state. It will be undertaken all across America next year. The last time redistricting took place was in 2010, when Gov. Sean Parnell was in office.

The 2011 Redistricting Board was made up of:

  • Robert Brodie, (appointed by Senate president)
  • PeggyAnn McConnochie, Vice Chairman, (appointed by governor)
  • Jim Holm (appointed by House speaker)
  • Marie Greene (appointed by Chief Justice)
  • John Torgerson, Chairman (appointed by governor)

It’s likely that Dunleavy will make his choices to the Redistricting Board before the Aug. 18 primary.

Then, Giessel will make her choice — maybe as a play to retain her seat in the primary she will pick a conservative, or maybe she’ll wait until after the primary to see what happens. She is on record saying she will use her pick to balance out the governor’s pick.

After that, it’s likely that Edgmon will choose — but he, too, is not expected to do so before the Aug. 18 primary.

Justice Bolger will probably go last. He is considered a liberal, and is plainly opposed to this governor. He’ll probably also use his pick to balance out whomever the governor chooses.

This means the redistricting board may have just two conservatives on it instead of the four that it would be expected to have, considering the makeup of the Legislature and the Governor’s Office.

That political makeup would normally indicate a different outcome: There are 23 Republicans in the House, 15 Democrats, and two Independent-Democrats.

In the Senate, there are 13 Republicans and 7 Democrats, but Senate President Giessel has become adversarial toward the Republican governor, and her pick is unpredictable.

The consequences of what a handful of House Republicans did when they put a Democrat in charge of the House back in February of 2019 will be felt in the next few weeks. Much is at stake for the state, and the Democrats are clearly aware of the play that is about to happen, since they and their surrogate organizations have remained silent about redistricting.

It’s clear that Redistricting Board will favor Democrats in a state where there are nearly twice as many Republicans as Democrats — 139,821 registered Republicans and 76, 779 registered Democrats. But the smoking gun document signed by a few Republicans in 2019 changed the course of history.

Donations Welcome


Written by

Suzanne Downing had careers in business and journalism before serving as the Director of Faith and Community-based Initiatives for Florida Gov. Jeb Bush and returning to Alaska to serve as speechwriter for Gov. Sean Parnell. Born on the Oregon coast, she moved to Alaska in 1969.

Latest comments

  • I doubt it. He is a major reason why we left Alaska.

  • Perhaps it is not Democrats the redistricting board will favor. Perhaps it is what are called “voters.”
    How the present redistricting boundaries were allowed to exist, in spite of judgments that they were clearly partisan and gerrymandered, is a mystery to many Alaskans. Mostly the ones who are paying attention.

    • Please give an example of a boundary that should not exist. I don’t think you can find one. Contrary to the liberals dogma that there is something wrong with these boundaries. They are just different from before. Times change the Valley has far outstripped the population of the rest of the state and should continue to gain representation.

      • “……..Times change the Valley has far outstripped the population of the rest of the state and should continue to gain representation………”

        Boy, Howdy. After 50 years of life here in the Valley, that sure hits home. This place has very little today that reminds me of the place I settled in so long ago, and this is just the beginning. And I knew it all along. Anybody looking at the region from the air has to realize it. Geography limits Anchorage growth and blesses (curses) the Valley with expanded growth. We WILL control the Legislature eventually the same way Anchorage has since WWII. It is inevitable.

  • Giessel is a flat out liar and should be physically removed from this State. She lies at every turn just listen to her ads playing she lies in them and should be charged with deceptive advertising

  • Big ups to Edgmon for screwing over the state of Alaska for the next 20 years with his welfare state legislation initiatives.

  • Anyone thinking about maybe voting for Gary Knopp should rethink their selection. We definitely have him as one of the instigators to thank for this mess.

  • Whatever comes of the new redistricting it will spend years working it’s way through the courts.

    • Steve-O, Depends on who wins, if the Democrats win any legal challenge to the plan by Republicans will be quickly tossed out of Court.

    • Hopefully, this little man, Edgmon, will be placed where he belongs. Back in the minority, with a play, plastic gavel and a baby bottle from which to nurse. Another peabrain in the House.

  • If these people spent 1/4 as much time dealing with the business of We the People, as they do on political maneuvering, we might get some problems solved in this state.

    Popularity contests and cliques were over in junior high school. Time to grow up.

  • Using the word honor and the name Edgmon in the same sentence will always lead to nonsense. Many can and sometimes do recall when Edgmon introduced his wife and daughter when they were in the House gallery while at the same time his illegitimate daughter was serving as a House page on the floor. That kind of stuff goes on all the time in Juneau but there is absolutely nothing that can be confused with honor. He can wear a granny dress on Fridays so suggest he is one thing or another, but don’t expect honorable conduct.

  • Little wonder why Tammie Wilson left the House in the middle of session.

  • Remember this: Giessel picked John Binkley. But Binkley only represented the Bush when serving as a legislator (Bethel). He never did, or could, get elected from his hometown (Fairbanks). Almost like giving the Bush two seats on the Redistricting Board…….thanks to Giessel and Edgmon.

%d bloggers like this: