Alaska U.S. District Court Judge Sharon Gleason on Tuesday issued an edict to the Mat-Su Borough School Board: Put 51 books back in the school libraries by Aug. 14, or else.
Gleason ruled against the district in a case brought by a radical Fairbanks attorney, Savannah Fletcher, who is running to represent Fairbanks in the Alaska Senate. She works as a “law fare” attorney for the Northern Justice Project.
In her ruling, the schools may not remove any additional books from the school library shelves until Judge Gleason says so.
The case goes back to 2023, when the district responded to parents and the public that was concerned about certain titles that were being placed in the libraries for children. Some of them were explicit sex manuals for gay sex, including how to have anal sex.
The district temporarily removed the books and then set up a committee to review them and decide which books could be returned. In the end, the committee chose seven books to return out of the nearly 60 that had been set aside for review.
Gleason agreed with Fletcher that children should have access to these books, including ones with pictures of men having oral sex with other men.
Some of the books are well-known controversial books for children. Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale is a dystopian novel about a society that is essentially a prison and rape camp, where women are held captive as breeding stock and where they are beaten into submission. The material is disturbing even for adults, and not all parents would believe their 14-year-old would have the maturity to read the novel.
Importantly, the judge decided that the public process was not good enough for her. Although the district was attempting to be responsive and responsible, the decisions about the books occurred over several meetings and citizen-led elected groups tend to work through things not on a straight line.
Gleason decided the process was imperfect and substituted her own perfect judgment for that of local citizens who are trying to make the best decisions, based on information coming at them from all directions.
Here is the judge’s ruling:
Who is Judge Sharon Gleason?
Gleason was nominated by President Barack Obama on April 6, 2011, to a seat vacated by John W. Sedwick. She was confirmed by the Senate on Nov. 15, 2011, and received commission on Jan. 4, 2012. She has served as chief judge since 2022 and with the current sex scandal that has enveloped the Alaska District Court, she is assigning most cases to herself.
Gleason is the only judge left in the three-member panel. Judge Joshua Kindred resigned after the scandal became publicly known and the other judgeship hasn’t been filled because of disagreements between Alaska Sen. Lisa Murkowski and Sen. Dan Sullivan about the process and the type of judge they want to recommend.
The ruling leaves Judge Gleason effectively in charge of determining content of all school libraries in Alaska, and her ruling can be inferred to extend to any and all curriculum in the schools, since library books in school libraries are just one aspect of school offerings. She will reach mandatory retirement age in three years. The federal judiciary is made up of judges nominated by a president and confirmed by the Senate, and who serve life terms. They cannot be voted out of office.
Gleason has damaged Alaska’s economy and endangered the citizens when she recently canceled all of Cook Inlet gas leases. She also tried to stop ConocoPhillips from proceeding on its Willow project, but she was overturned by the Ninth Circuit.
Because of the short timeframe Gleason has given the citizen government of the Mat-Su Borough School District to respond, it’s likely that the district will appeal the decision to the Ninth Circuit and to the U.S. Supreme Court.