Connect with:
Sunday, April 21, 2019
HomeIntel 907After Medicaid expansion: Alaskans are failing the health test

After Medicaid expansion: Alaskans are failing the health test

(3-minute read) HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS, NOT MUCH YET TO SHOW

Alaskans are surviving cancer better, are slapping each other less, and are quitting smoking.

But according to the Healthy Alaska Scorecard update from the Alaska Department of Health and Social Services, there’s a lot of work ahead to get Alaskans’ health on track.

We’re still too fat, we drink too much, and we’re couch potatoes. Plus, too many of us kill ourselves.

Those are just a few of the findings released last week by the department. Commissioner Adam Crum said that while there are some improvements, there are plenty of health indicators not worthy of bragging rights.

The data compares baseline information in over 25 health indicator categories from 2010 to the years 2017 and 2018. There are a couple of indicators only updated as far as 2016.

Only one of the categories is considered “on track” — meaning it’s meeting the expectation of the department for progress. That is the increase in the percentage of rural community housing units with water and sewer services. In Alaskan terms, this means running water and no honey buckets.

But as for accessing a doctor, progress has been slight, in spite of the billions of dollars spent to expand Medicaid to working adults without children.

In 2017, 13.6 percent said they could not afford to see a doctor, compared with the baseline rate of 14.7 percent from years earlier. DHSS claims progress in this area — progress of 1 percent.

For Alaska Natives, there’s been more progress in access to doctors. The percentage of that population who could not afford to see a doctor went from 13.2 in 2010 down to 11 percent in 2017.

The number of Alaskans admitted to hospitals for cases that could have been prevented with high-quality preventative care (based on industry definitions) was also lackluster. It was 7.1 percent in 2010, but rose to 7.3 percent in 2017. Medicaid was supposed to fix the problem of hospital emergency admissions due to lack of access to a doctor.

Alcohol mortality rates have also increased at an alarming rate since 2010. For every 100,000 Alaskans, there were 16.3 deaths in 2010, but it creeped up to 19 deaths per 100,000 in 2017.

On the other hand, binge drinking is down in both underage drinkers and those of legal age.

View the chart with all 25 health measurement scores here.

NATIVE HEALTH OUTCOMES STILL A CONCERN

A population subset that has benefited most from Medicaid expansion is Alaska Natives. Some improvements in health care access are noted in a separate report, such as access to prenatal care during the first trimester of pregnancy, which saw a 4 percent improvement.

Cigarette use is also down among Natives, as it is in the general population. The percentage of high schoolers who don’t smoke went from 59.2 percent to over 70.9 percent in the time between 2010 and 2017.

Cancer mortality is down.

But other concerns, such as suicide among Alaska Native adults, has skyrocketed since 2010, from 36.4 per 100,000 to 57.3 per 100,000.

The “Native only” chart shows no data at all for the number of rapes among that population. Neither does it show the reported rate of child maltreatment.

But in the overall population report for Natives and non-Natives, these numbers have worsened. (Note: this can be skewed because of a reduction in stigma in telling someone what happened leads to more reporting of these crimes.)

View the scorecard with the Alaska Native health outcomes here.

COSTS EXPLODING

The state’s Medicaid program is an open checkbook. Those enrolled will have their health care paid for by the state and federal governments without a cap, which allows the program to continue to expand, and always come back for supplemental funding.

During last year’s Senate Finance Committee hearings, both Sens. Anna MacKinnon and Peter Micciche expressed grave concern that the costs were exploding after they received a supplemental request from the Walker Administration of $170 million for the 2019 budget.

“When Medicaid was expanded, it was expanded with a set of assumptions that were simply incorrect,” Micciche said at the time. “There has to be a point where we have a bottom line of understanding what the end result is going to be. I mean, it is literally an open checkbook.”

Gov. Michael Dunleavy’s 2020 budget, due on Feb. 13, will likely have a different approach to what his administration has inherited, a health care system with not enough effective limits in spending and a substantial amount of fraud.

Most of traditional Medicaid enrollment — pre-expansion — is funded in a 50-50 split between the State and the Federal government. The expansion population has the Federal government paying about 90 percent of the cost, with the State picking up the remainder, at least for now.

Some costs for Medicaid have started to flatten since SB 74 was passed in 2016. To read the most recent report to the Legislature on cost-avoidance measures that have resulted from the recent Medicaid reform bill, check this link.

Donations Welcome
Written by

Suzanne Downing had careers in business and journalism before serving as the Director of Faith and Community-based Initiatives for Florida Gov. Jeb Bush and returning to Alaska to serve as speechwriter for Gov. Sean Parnell. Born on the Oregon coast, she moved to Alaska in 1969.

Latest comments

  • Kidney stones can be dissolved by drinking a little vinegar in the morning for a week. Most cancer can be cured with heat at or above 104F as cancer cells can’t live above 104F. Most thyroid issues can be resolved by taking Black Cohosh Root. Most gall bladder stones can be flushed out by drinking two cups of olive oil. A lot of auto immune problems are caused by aluminum poisoning but doctors don’t know how to diagnose heavy metal poisoning, nor how to do a hair analysis to test for it. Until we combine Naturopathic medicine with modern medicine, we are not going to root out the corruption in modern medicine and reduce costs.

    • The quacks out there are dying to get their hands on the federal gravy train.

      • Whatever happened to Dr. Rowen? I literally lost track after the great hue and cry over appointing him to the State Medical Board.

      • Treatment methods must be approved to get paid. It’s not quacks. My brother and nephew both got rid of their kidney stones last year with vinegar. All the things I said are true and really do help people better than taking a KNIFE to them!!! Or loosing a body part. It is good to be skeptical, I don’t mind.

      • If its a gravy train, then it must be out of gravy. The reimbursements to providers of Medicaid and Medicare patients are peanuts. Government funded reimbursements are not enough to keep a practice open.

  • I live in a village. Our kids are half Yupik. I don’t know how the state figured that there’s any Native out here without healthcare.

    There’s only 4 white guys and as close as I can tell, we’re the only ones that deal with health costs.

  • To Commissioner Crum we respectfully suggest:
    .
    Put your house in order first.
    .
    Apparently the best your Department, its 25 councils and commissions, and Alaska’s medical-dental-insurance-pharmaceutical-lobbyist industry, can produce is a “Healthy Alaska Scorecard”
    which Alaskans predictably fail, clear evidence of yet another crisis which can be solved only with more money and government intervention.
    .
    If Alaskans are such abject failures in their “Healthy Alaska Scorecards”, it seems reasonable to conclude that the 25 mini bureaucracies are useless and should be abolished forthwith.
    .
    But no, Alaska’s medical-dental-insurance-pharmaceutical-lobbyist industry flourishes unchecked while:
    .
    API employees feel obliged to make a public spectacle out of the Department’s failure to provide them with suitable on-the-job protection from dangerously mentally ill customers,
    .
    mental-health care professionals are inundated by idiotic requirements such as imaginative treatment goals for the chronically mentally ill (think about it!) when keeping them out of hospital and jail are, in practicality, major achievements,
    .
    professionally unqualified entrepreneurs may operate assisted-living facilities for the chronically mentally ill,
    .
    productive Alaskans, particularly Medicare customers, find it more economical (and sadly sometimes, survivable) to do their part for “Healthy Alaska” by going Outside or abroad for reasonably priced, competent, (or available) medical, dental, and pharmaceutical service,
    .
    mystifyingly, certain groups in-state, such as public employees, Alaska Native groups, and able-bodied Medicaid recipients don’t have that issue but apparently do no better at their “Healthy Alaska Scorecard”,
    .
    and more, so much more.
    .
    Here’s a challenge, Commissioner Crum: Your mission statement, “to promote and protect the health and well-being of Alaskans”, suggests it might be helpful to listen to what Alaskans really need for health and well being, before the Department and its 25 councils and commissions decide what’s best for them.

    Why not set up times with hosts of morning and afternoon talk-radio shows and listen to what health-care consumers and providers have to say. If nothing else, you’re likely hear unique perspectives on what “to promote and protect health and well-being of Alaskans” actually means to those you serve.

    • And to add to the Medicare comment, recently our primary care provider ceased business, requiring a search for another in Fairbanks. There are no physicians/NP/PA taking new Medicare patients except for the Federally subsidized health center. Clearly medicare is a failure of huge proportions like all other government agencies and so we pay for promised care where none is available.