Tom Williams: A remaining leadership opportunity for Gov. Dunleavy

By
GUEST CONTRIBUTOR
-
15

By TOM WILLIAMS

Last December, I penned an MRAK column challenging Gov. Mike Dunleavy to ensure his administration accomplishes a critical infrastructure project for Alaska, namely a ferry terminal at Cascade Point, 33 miles north of the existing Auke Bay terminal.  

Read: Leadership and integrity or smoke and mirrors on Cascade Point?

While the Dunleavy administration has made some limited progress on this project, the apparent lack of urgency by Gov.Dunleavy’s Department of Transportation is very troubling.

This project has been slow-rolled by DOT despite being fully funded and potentially construction ready.  It makes one wonder if this is by design or by a lack of leadership.

Notwithstanding DOT’s extremely slow progress to date, Governor Dunleavy still has an excellent opportunity to not only exhibit leadership but to actually accomplish a ready-to-go critical infrastructure project that is of significant benefit to all Alaskans, not just those in SE Alaska.  So, let’s review just why the Governor should make sure it happens without any further delay by asking a few critical questions.

Why is a Ferry Terminal at Cascade Point worth doing?

The principal reasons are:

  1. It eliminates approximately 30 miles of a ferry run that parallels an already existing highway, most of which has been improved in the last several years. That shaves 60 miles off of each round trip;
  2. It reduces operational costs for the Alaska Marine Highway System (AMHS), allowing scarce state AMHS dollars to be spent on routes that do not have roads;
  3. It shortens the travel time between Alaska’s State capital Juneau and the road system, as well as Haines and Skagway.  That is a positive result not only for the residents of those three communities, but for all Alaska residents and visitors passing through SE Alaska.
  4. It enables the Alaska Class Ferries, specifically designed for the routes between Juneau, Haines and Skagway, to be utilized as designed without expensive modifications; and
  5. The resulting improvement to regional transportation will provide increased economic opportunities for the region and the state, since hard transportation infrastructure is always a critical element for and almost always leads to economic prosperity.

Just how will this project increase regional and statewide prosperity?

  • Southcentral and interior Alaska businesses already know that efficient and cost-effective transportation systems are critical to their economic health and prosperity. The AMHS is a critical element for their businesses, especially as it relates to tourist traffic.  Reducing the travel time and increasing transportation reliability within the northern Lynn Canal corridor will allow for increased commerce between Southeast Alaska and the rest of the State as well as the Canadian Yukon and British Columbia.  As such this necessary improvement to the operation the AMHS directly benefits the statewide economy, while putting Alaskans to work constructing the terminal and other related improvements.

Is there funding for a ferry terminal at Cascade Point?

  • Yes. Several years ago, the legislature appropriated $42 million of state funds to improve Juneau access.  Those funds are still available to pay for this project. Right now. No additional legislative approval is needed.  But some legislators would like to use those funds for projects in the own districts or to bolster the current unsustainable AMHS model.

Wouldn’t it be better to spend those funds to match federal funding for a road out of Juneau up Lynn Canal rather than a ferry terminal at the north end of the exiting road?

  • Unfortunately, inasmuch as that project has been proposed, discussed and worked on for more than 50 years without success, the reality is that it is highly unlikely that a road up Lynn Canal will be built anytime in the foreseeable future without a restart of the environmental permitting process.  
  • In the near term, the Biden administration is likely to oppose it even if Juneau, Haines, and Skagway all agreed to support it.  But even if a road up Lynn Canal were to move forward, a ferry terminal at Cascade Point would provide a backup should there be road closures for any reason, as called for in the Juneau Access scoping documents.

Cascade Point is owned by Goldbelt, an Alaskan Native Corporation, and not the State.  So how can the State have a ferry terminal on Goldbelt’s land?

  • Goldbelt, as a willing and able partner for this project, has offered at a reasonable cost a long-term land lease to the State for the ferry terminal.  In addition, at one point DOT asked if Goldbelt would be interested in building the terminal to lease back to the state.  Goldbelt has advised the State that Goldbelt would be very willing to provide the State a such a proposal.

Has Goldbelt provided DOT such a proposal?

  1. To provide a proposal, Goldbelt needed some terminal criteria from DOT.  After many months DOT finally provided Goldbelt some criteria and Goldbelt is providing their proposal to DOT. 

Is there political support for a ferry terminal at Cascade Point?

  1. Absolutely.  Governor Dunleavy’s Alaska Marine Highway Working Group lead by Admiral Barrett, the Juneau Chamber of Commerce, the Alaska Committee, First Things First Alaska, and the International Union of Operating Engineers, Local 302, in addition to Governor Dunleavy himself, are all on the formal record as supporting this project.  In addition, Senate President Peter Micciche, Senate Transportation Committee Chair Rob Meyer, northern southeast Sen. Jesse Kiehl, Juneau Rep. Andi Story, Haines Mayor Doug Olerud, and Juneau Mayor Beth Weldon have all expressed various levels of support. Previous DOT staff charged with analyzing the project have also been supportive.

Is there political opposition to a ferry terminal at Cascade Point?  If so, why?

  1. While I have not identified any formal opposition to the project, the ferry unions and those politicians who would prefer to use the funds elsewhere for their own benefit are the likely suspects.  

The ferry unions and some politicians appear to want to throw money at an unsustainable ferry model rather than make necessary changes to improve service while reducing costs.  But a terminal a Cascade Point does just that. It allows for improved service while reducing costs in both the short and the long term. 

In addition, given DOT staff’s slow performance in moving the project forward, it appears that there is likely opposition to the project within the upper to mid-levels of the DOT bureaucracy.

Recently the governor stated on KINY Radio that he supports hard infrastructure projects.  Well Governor, a Cascade Point ferry terminal is a fully funded, common sense, budget-wise, politically supported, and beneficial project that you, as Governor, can make happen.

Don’t let the naysayers convince you that Cascade Point is something that can wait for a second term. Successful leaders do not procrastinate or squander silver platter opportunities.  This project can and should happen now. It is a win for all Alaskans, you and future generations. “Carpe diem,” Gov. Dunleavy. Exercise some leadership by ensuring your DOT bureaucracy makes it happen without any further delay.

Tom Williams is a 44-year resident of Juneau with both private sector and public sector management and financial experience, including 18 years of Alaska executive and legislative branch service.

15 COMMENTS

  2. Yeah but the fact remains that a lot of us don’t want the ferry. We don’t want increased access to our towns. If you want to travel freely between communities in southeast. Buy a boat. Don’t make the taxpayers fund your way of life. If you need to go to Costco once a week then move to the city.

  3. Dunleavy and leadership don’t belong in the same sentence. He wet himself in Wasilla and it’s was game over since.

    Leadership requires things Dunleavy doesn’t have. Conviction, a spine, willingness to stand and fight.

    The solution to this issue isn’t Cascade Point. It’s a road all the way to Scagway. But that takes drive and a willingness to play bare knuckle politics.

    Is short, someone besides the Cowardly Lion.

  4. Dunleavy could tell the DOT get busy or get gone. But that requires the DOT believe he’ll actually get rid of people until the remainder get motivated.

    During the Dunleavy debacle on this he has never done is actually bring heat on the AK swamp. Even when he gets concessions he gives them back.

    How many state workers got laid off, let go, or even furloughed during Covid? Zero.

    • Okay Skippy, lets unpack this for you. When we lay off or furlough unionized government workers, that means we pay them full salary and benefits to stay home remodel their homes. That is one of the reasons Home Depot is thriving during the pandemic while other businesses fade. There is no such thing as “letting go” of a union government worker.

  5. Something else. Cascade Point is well away from any population center. The road is pitiful shape. There is nowhere to get gas past Auke Bay.

    Cascade Point is a Bridge to Nowhere exercise in futility. It’s freaking pointless.

    If we must do this stupidity at least build it all the way to Berners Bay so the miners can drive to work or maybe even build a community out there.

    Go to Scagway or don’t bother.

    • Agreed. Plus, not all who travel on the ferry have vehicles. Will there be a reliable shuttle or taxi service available for each docking? What will that cost a passenger?

    • Here we go again Skippy. Cascade is at Berners Bay. You obviously never even read the article. The project eliminates the need for crew quarters and creates a true daily-turnaround ferry rather than an ocean-liner style service. It will save the system $millions. If anyone runs out of gas on a 30-mile road trip then they deserve the consequences that befall them (a need for 2-gallons of fuel). By the way, I drove out there last week and the road is just fine; its been upgraded just 5-years ago. Your point regarding the road condition is a failed attempt at a red-herring fallacy.

  6. I fully agree with the analysis by Tom Williams and his urging of the governor to move forward on the Cascade Point Terminal..

    Increasing travel by. roads that parallel ferry routes in Southeast Alaska coupled with shorter ferry runs between roadheads reduces fuel and other operating costs.

  7. Hey Tom, NEWSFLASH! There has already been “expensive modifications” done to the Alaska Class ferries. Alaska Class= over budget, prohibitively expensive to operate and maintain, and sold for 10 cents on the dollar.

    • Jay, NEWSFLASH, you are way off base on this one. You are confusing Alaska Class with Fast Ferries which were a failed boondoggle of the Knowles administration. Alaska Class were designed specifically for the daily round-trip run between Cascade and Haines/Skagway. This plan enables the crews to sleep in their own homes rather than onboard…. saving $millions over time. The boondoggle Fast Ferries are now working in Spain.

  9. A decidedly well thought out and written missive Mr. Tom Williams. Could I offer one suggestion? Perhaps the leadership at Goldbelt might consider sweetening the deal with adding a nice Kayak launching dock along with parking and a Latte stand serving organic muffins. Appeal to the Greenies here a bit. I foresee a host of Subaru’s unloading North Face Gortex clad supporters of your idea. Berners Bay has long been a Mecca for these people, perhaps make it easier to access? As for the Guv… believe me when I say he will be all in once he sees a way to appease his enemies…

  10. You mean Dunleavy would have to tell his DOT Commissioner to do something again? Like the valley delegation raising awareness to DOT’s dumb decision to turn off the lights at night on the Glenn Highway out to the valley which was overturned in about a day?
    Or when Dunleavy had to order DOT to reopen the SilverTip Maintenance Camp near the Hope Junction?
    How in the hell is John MacKinnon still DOT Commissioner? WOW. Dunleavy should have never hired him, and he certainly should have let him go spend more time with his family after such embarrassments. Good luck with this attempt. But it appears Dunleavy doesn’t want a second term.

Comments are closed.