Lawmakers love to tinker. They can’t help themselves. Deep in the DNA of nearly every politician is the pathological belief that the worst thing a legislature can do for the public is … nothing.
Forget Jefferson’s old maxim that “the government which governs best, governs least.” Sorry, Tom, what really excites the political class is meddling. Tampering. Grabbing whatever levers of power they can reach. It’s not ideological. It’s instinctual. And it’s on full display right now in Juneau.
When lawmakers aren’t slashing the Permanent Fund dividend or floating new taxes to prop up budget-busting boondoggles like unsustainable pensions and a broken education system, they’ve found a new arena for flexing muscle: a turf war over constitutional boundaries.
Exhibit A: Senate Bill 183.
On paper, it looks harmless, dull, even. Just a bit of “cleanup” language. (Pro tip: most power grabs start out looking boring.)
The bill would force executive branch departments to hand over information to the Legislature’s auditor in any format the auditor or their legislative overlords demanded. Refusal? That would be illegal.
This is more than oversight. SB 183 blatantly infringes on executive branch autonomy. It empowers legislative auditors to dictate how data, including sensitive or proprietary information, is delivered, regardless of operational burden or security risks. That’s especially problematic in complex areas like oil and gas tax audits, which often involve trade secrets and confidential commercial data.
Imagine a state employee, already buried in technical work, being told to repackage geophysical models or Medicaid financials — not because it’s necessary, but because a legislative staffer prefers PowerPoint over Excel, with 12-point Allegri font in off-black. Sound absurd? That’s exactly the kind of power this bill hands over.
So why is this happening? Simple: a long-running feud. Legislative auditors and Department of Revenue staff have been at odds for nearly a decade, under multiple governors and commissioners. The friction finally came into the open during a House Rules Committee hearing.
Revenue officials testified they’d already provided the requested data. The problem? The format. Legislators wanted the data redone their way — even if it meant hundreds of extra hours for agency staff.
The auditor’s response? Too bad. Get to work. And make sure the color palette is pleasing.
This bill isn’t about transparency. It’s about control. It’s a legislative overreach that sets a dangerous precedent: allowing lawmakers to micromanage executive branch functions under the guise of “accountability.” Today it’s data formatting. Tomorrow, who knows?
Rep. Chuck Kopp insists courts will uphold this power play. He might want to check his case history. In 2020, the Legislature tried a similar move, inserting language into a Covid-era bill that would automatically reject the governor’s appointees if not confirmed by a deadline. The Alaska Supreme Court, hardly a fan club for the current governor, struck it down as a clear overreach.
Maybe, just maybe, in the closing days of session, lawmakers could set aside this petty bureaucratic feud. How about focusing on, say, passing a budget? Avoiding new taxes? Not driving the economy into a ditch?
Just a thought.
Suzanne Downing is founder and editor of Must Read Alaska.
Beautifully written and an important message for legislators in their closing days of Session. The PFD is as important to Alaskans as is a reasonable education budget with policy language. Any steering away of a statutory PFD to qualifed Alaskans will be grounds for contempt against the future candidates, especially the 2026 governor’s race.
“Pro tip: most power grabs start out looking boring.” Are you referring to Project 2025?
I’m glad you used the term “nearly” all politicians. I watched for years as media people would take microphones and shove them into a newly elected official’s faces. The first thing they would ask–“What’s the first legislation you’re going to sponsor”? I believe we HAVE enough laws and regulations but we don’t always follow them and enforce the laws already in place. I served my two terms on the Wasilla City Council and my biggest source of pride was to have NEVER put forth a new ordinance. I participated in the back and forth discussions on the different ideas others put forth, but I didn’t add any more rules to Wasilla. I wasn’t being lazy, it was a very deliberate decision on my part. Thank you for verifying that I tried to do the right thing.
Thanks for calling it out as it is Suzanne!!
This isn’t being represented. This is being ruled.
Our legislators are Ditch Diving the state into chaos with the tax more spend more agenda
“Government is not eloquence, it is not reason, it is force! Like fire, it is a dangerous servant, and a fearful master.”
– A far-right radical known as George Washington
And our governor needs to throw cold water on this fire by vetoing it, right away.
Again, the light of truth shining in the legislative darkness. Thank you Suzanne.