Sunday, December 21, 2025
Home Blog Page 1661

Governor Walker removes Patriot from 9-11 ‘Patriot Day’

44

Patriot Day is so … patriotic. Maybe a bit too patriotic for Alaska Gov. Bill Walker.

Since 2001, Sept. 11 has been known as Patriot Day, designated first by Congress and President George W. Bush, then by President Barack Obama, and now by President Donald Trump.

Alaska governors also declared Sept. 11 Patriot Day, a day to remember the fallen, the heroes, and to honor the men and women who went to war after the terrorist attacks on U.S. soil. Many of them are in Afghanistan today in a war that has gone on a long, long time.

This year it’s Patriot Day all over America on Monday. Just not in the 49th State.

Gov. Walker has declared it “September 11 Commemoration Day,” a day where “we as Americans reflect on the importance to our nation of freedom, tolerance, patriotism, diversity, and respect for others, and are grateful for the rights and freedoms that we hold as Americans;”

This word play doesn’t happen by accident. Someone changed it from Patriot Day to Commemoration Day. Someone approved it. And the governor signed it. Did he know that he had taken patriotism out of Patriot Day? Of course he did.

The Walker Administration made a decision to remove not only the overriding concept of patriotism but to erase the emotional reaction Americans have to the horrific attack on our nation, the evil that incited it, and heroism that followed. Now it’s really just about community service.

On the day before our 425th Brigade left Alaska for Afghanistan, as it has done several times before since 9-11, Walker made no mention of the heroism and courage of our men and women in uniform.

Instead, the word “patriotism” was tucked in among politically correct verbiage that completely missed the point of the day: We were attacked. Innocents died. Our freedoms have been curtailed. Our men and women in uniform have fought, been injured, and many have died.

Instead, the Walker proclamation phoned it in with a nearly clinical nod to the most heinous attack on American soil — ever.

A CONTRAST

Even President Obama understood the meaning of Patriot Day, as evidenced by his eloquent 2015 proclamation:

On September 11, 2001, America experienced the worst terrorist attack in her history when nearly 3,000 men, women, and children were taken from us, leaving their families and our Nation with a void that can never be filled. But those who brought hate to our shores and smoke to our skies did not expect our country to emerge stronger, and our beacons of hope and freedom to shine brighter as a result. In the years since, we have stood strong as one people ‑‑ determined to further embolden our country’s character with acts of endurance and strength; rebuilding and resilience; renewal and progress. In remembrance of the innocent victims who lost their lives and in honor of the families they left behind, let us continue to answer these heinous acts by serving our communities, lifting the lives of our fellow citizens, and spreading the hope that others tried to dim that day.

The compassion that rose in the hearts and minds of the American people on September 11 still serves as the ultimate rebuke to the evil of those who attacked us. First responders who risked and gave their lives to rescue others demonstrated the unwavering heroism that defines our great Nation. Volunteers donated time, money, and blood to ensure wounds gave way to healing and recovery. Young people, raised until then in a time of peace, stepped forward to serve and defend us, and meet the threats of our time. And people from across our country and the world joined together in the days that followed to stand up and turn toward one another with open arms, making of a tragedy something the terrorists could never abide ‑‑ a tribute of hope over fear, and love over hate.

As we reflect on the lives we lost and pay tribute to the families who still live with extraordinary pain, let us resolve to continue embodying the American spirit that no act of terror can ever extinguish. I call on all Americans to observe this National Day of Service and Remembrance with acts of selflessness and charity. In doing so, we prove once again that the power of those who seek to harm and to destroy is never greater than our power to persevere and to build. I encourage everyone to visit www.Serve.gov to learn of the many opportunities available to give back to others and to reaffirm the fundamental truth that we are our brothers’ and our sisters’ keepers, and that we can forge a brighter future together.

Today, we continue our unfaltering march forward, enduring in the perennial optimism that drives us and brightening the light that the darkness of evil can never overcome. We remember and yearn for the presence of the beautiful lives lost, and we recommit to honoring their memories by shaping the days to come ‑‑ in as stark a contrast as possible to those who took them from us ‑‑ with courage, liberty, and love…

The words of President Donald Trump’s Patriot Day proclamation are equally moving, and include this passage:

On Patriot Day, we honor the nearly 3,000 innocent lives taken from us on September 11, 2001, and all of those who so nobly aided their fellow citizens in America’s time of need.  We rededicate ourselves to the ideals that define our country and unite us as one, as we commemorate all the heroes who lost their lives saving others.
 
September 11, 2001, will forever be one of the most tragic days in American history.  Through the unimaginable despair, however, ordinary Americans etched into our history remarkable illustrations of bravery, of sacrifice for one another, and of dedication to our shared values.  The shock from the indelible images of the smoke rising from the World Trade Center and Pentagon gave way to countless inspiring videos of co-workers helping one another to safety; of heroes running into collapsing buildings to save the innocent people trapped within; and to the unforgettable story of the patriots who charged the cockpit of Flight 93 to save untold numbers of lives.  These heroes moved us with their bravery.  They make us proud to be Americans. 

THE 4-25TH DEPLOYS

Not mentioned by Gov. Walker’s proclamation was any recognition that this week, more than 2,000 Alaska-based soldiers are deploying  to Afghanistan from the U.S. Army Alaska’s 4th Brigade Combat Team, 25th Infantry Division based at JBER.

That is nearly double what was anticipated to be deployed just a few months ago. Spartan Brigade personnel will be assisting the Afghanistan Security Forces. The unit has not been sent to Afghanistan since 2011-12. Each one of those soldiers has a family who worries.

During a deployment ceremony on Friday, Sen. Dan Sullivan spoke to the troops in the most heartfelt terms:

“There was nothing — and I mean nothing — that was going to keep me away from attending this deployment ceremony of the 425.

“I am so proud of this unit. Each one of you has done what less than 1 percent of all Americans do, and that is raise your right hand voluntarily to support and defend the Constitution and protect your fellow Americans, and we cannot thank you enough.”

“We all know that the best units get the toughest missions,” Sullivan continued, acknowledging to the troops that he knew they were going into harm’s way, and reciting the words of Winston Churchill, who said, “We at home sleep safely at night because rough men stand ready to visit violence on those who would harm us. Thank you for being those rough men and rough women, which every free society needs.”

Sen. Sullivan had been full-time Marine before returning to Alaska and was in the Marine Reserves when the nation was attacked on 9-11. He returned to Washington D.C. to work at the White House on national security issues.

For Sen. Sullivan’s service, as well as the service of hundreds of thousands of other Americans, our Governor is recognizing them by watering down the importance of Patriot Day with a new, politically correct name.

Federalist Society’s Leonard Leo keynotes religious liberty dinner

0

Alaska Family Council’s annual Religious Liberty Dinner features Leonard Leo, executive vice president of the Federalist Society, which advances limited, constitutional government.

The event is at 7 pm, Sept. 15, at O’Malley’s on the Green in Anchorage. The New Yorker Magazine described Leo as an “impresario,” and one of the most influential people in forming the conservative side of the U.S. Supreme Court — “a convener and a networker, and he has met and cultivated almost every important Republican lawyer in more than a generation.”

“When Leonard walks in that room, everyone knows who he is,” Carrie Severino, chief counsel of the Judicial Crisis Network, another conservative organization that worked on the confirmation of Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch said to the reporter. “If you care about the conservative legal movement, you always take note of Leonard.”

Leo has advised President Donald Trump on judicial selection, helped to manage the Justice Gorsuch selection and confirmation process, and served as a member of the transition team.

“At the Gorsuch hearings, which took place in the Hart Senate Office Building, Leo acted as the unofficial mayor of the room. Sometimes he sat in the back, so that he could kibbitz with reporters, and sometimes he sat up front, behind Trump Administration officials,” the New Yorker wrote.

He organized the outside coalition efforts in support of the John Roberts and Samuel Alito U.S. Supreme Court confirmations, and, in 2004, was the Bush-Cheney presidential campaign’s Catholic strategist.

Leonard was appointed by President George W. Bush to three terms to the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom, where he served as chairman. He was also a U.S. Delegate to the UN Council and UN Commission on Human Rights during the Bush Administration.

He was awarded the 2009 Bradley Prize, along with the other founders and directors of the Federalist Society, for his work in advancing freedom and the rule of law.

He is the coeditor of Presidential Leadership: Rating the Best and the Worst in the White House, as well as the author of opinions in the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, and Washington Post.

Leonard holds degrees from Cornell University and Cornell Law School. He resides in Northern Virginia, where he and his wife Sally have raised their seven children.

[Read: The New Yorker’s, “Conservative Pipeline to the Supreme Court”]

Governor of Virgin Island orders gun seizure

4

U.S. Virgin Islands Governor Kenneth Mapp signed an executive order this week telling the U.S. National Guard to seize weapons and other private property as needed, according to documents acquired by The Daily Caller web site.

The Daily Caller obtained a copy of the governor’s order that directs Deborah Howell, the U.S. Virgin Islands adjutant general of the U.S. National Guard, to seize weapons, ammunition, and other property that may be needed for the National Guard’s emergency mission during recovery from Hurricane Irma.

Irma killed four people in the U.S. Virgin Islands and caused widespread damage to parts of the islands’ infrastructure, including to a major hospital.

“The Adjutant General is authorized and directed to seize arms, ammunition, explosives, incendiary material and any other property that may be required by the military forces for the performance of this emergency mission, in accordance with the Rules of Force promulgated by the Virgin Islands National Guard and approved by the Virgin Islands Department of Justice,” the order reads.

Like Gov. Bill Walker of Alaska, Mapp is a Republican who ran as an “independent,” without a political party in 2014, and assumed office a month after Walker was sworn in as Alaska’s governor. Walker and Mapp are the only two unaffiliated governors.

Born in Brooklyn, New York, Mapp’s family moved to Saint Croix in the Virgin Islands in 1961.

In the interview with Tucker Carlson on Fox News, Mapp attempted to back away from the order and explained that seizing weapons meant the National Guard could buy the weapons from stores.

Mapp told Carlson he didn’t mean the Adjutant General to “go into people’s homes” but to get what it needs “as the government acquires property on the open market without having to “go through the procurement processes of the government.”

During Hurricane Katrina preparations in 2005, New Orleans Police Chief Eddie Compass Chief of Police and Mayor Ray Nagin signed a similar order and police seized guns, rifles and other weapons in door-to-door searches.

“Only law enforcement are allowed to have weapons,” the Chief Compass ordered.

That blanket weapons ban led to Congress passing the Disaster Recovery Personal Protection Act (Vittner Amendment) in 2006, to prohibit authorities from confiscating weapons during emergencies.

Co-chair of Republican National Committee headlining fundraiser

1

Bob Paduchik, co-chair of the Republican National Committee, will arrive in Anchorage on Sept. 18 for workshops with state party leaders. He’ll be the featured guest at a fundraiser for the Alaska Republican Party on Sept. 19.

Paduchik was the Ohio state director for the Trump-Pence presidential campaign, and served as campaign manager for Ohio Sen. Rob Portman’s successful campaign in 2010. He was also Ohio state director for the Bush-Cheney presidential campaigns in 2000 and 2004. Bush carried the state both times.

He served as Deputy Assistant Secretary for Intergovernmental Affairs at the U.S. Department of Energy.

Paduchik is coming at the invitation of Alaska Republican Party Chairman Tuckerman Babcock, who spoke to him in Nashville, Tenn. at the fall meeting of the RNC.

“This just shows the enthusiasm and excitement at the national level for building the RNC, and we are just honored to have him. It will be a real opportunity to learn first hand what is going on nationally,” said Babcock.

The cohost list is a who’s-who of conservative Alaska politicos, 90 in all, including Sen. Dan Sullivan, Congressman Don Young, and a host of state senators and representatives.

The Sept. 19 reception starts at 5:30 pm and will be held at Davis Constructors, 6591 A Street, Anchorage. The suggested donation is $250, with a $5,000 maximum.

Indian country expansion continues: Fort Yukon, Ninilchik

0

Acre-by-acre, Indian Country is expanding in Alaska in 2017.

The Bureau of Indian Affairs has two more applications to create Indian reservations (Land into Trust) in Alaska: Ninilchik and Fort Yukon.

The Ninilchik Village has requested that 2.5 acres be placed into federal trust status. The land is located at 66590 Oil Well Road in Ninilchick and houses the Ninilchik Village Transit Facility, which provides transportation assistance to the community, according to a notice from BIA. No change in land use is proposed. Ninilchik is located in the Kenai Peninsula Borough.

The Native Village of Fort Yukon, also known as the Gwichyaa Zhee Gwich’in Tribal Government, has requested the federal government take ownership of contiguous lots in the city of Fort Yukon totaling 83,750 square feet.

The lots currently contain the tribal government building and the Chief Ezias Loola Cultural Center. No change in land use is proposed. Fort Yukon lies in the unorganized borough, so there is no local taxing authority.

The Chief Ezias Looa Cultural Center. (Photo from Dancing With the Spirit.)

COMMENT PERIOD

The State of Alaska has 30 days to comment on the transfer of the land to federal reservation status, which exempts it from taxing authority.

Alaskans with an opinion on the matter can send comments to  [email protected]. Comments must be received by Friday, September 22, 2017.

Comments can also be submitted to the Alaska Region BIA, 3601 C Street, Suite 1100, Anchorage, AK 99503.

In April the Central Council Tlingit and Haida Indian Tribes of Alaska applied to BIA to place one-fifth of an acre of land, in three parcels, in downtown Juneau into federal trust status. The land is being used as a parking lot and one section is a vacant lot. BIA has not issued a decision on that application.

In January, BIA approved an application by Craig Tribal Association to place 1.08 acres into trust. It was the first under the Obama-era revised rule for taking tribal land into trust in Alaska

Balash confirmation hearing indicates smooth path

1

Joe Balash, former Department of Natural Resources commissioner for Alaska, and former Chief of Staff to Sen. Dan Sullivan, was presented to the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee on Wednesday for confirmation.

In his statement to the committee, Balash recalled that as a teen he spent his time “chasing salmon wherever his Subaru could go.” Growing up fishing and learning about the salmon life cycle helped him appreciate the importance of clean habitat.

“At the same time, I began to learn about the Permanent Fund dividend, and where our state’s wealth came from,” he said. He came to understand that resource development and good wildlife habitat are often compatible.

Balash, if confirmed, is the new Assistant Secretary of Interior for Land and Minerals Management at the Department of Interior.

Balash is from North Pole. On an interim basis until officially confirmed, he runs the Bureau of Land Management, the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, and other agencies within Interior that have authority over so much of Alaska’s land and, by extension, its economy.

Gov. Bill Walker, upon his election in November, 2014, hastily replaced Balash as head of the Department of Natural Resources with his own pick, Mark Myers. Myers resigned within two years, and was replaced by Andy Mack of PT Capital, the private equity firm co-founded by Alice Rogoff, publisher of the now bankrupt Alaska Dispatch News.

Balash told the committee that as the head of Alaska DNR, he helped eliminate more than 50 percent of the permitting backlog in the agency.

The backlog of permit applications at DOI number in the thousands.

“Ultimately, I would seek to perform a similar review” at Interior, he said, adding that “the overall management approach needs to reflect the fact that these lands belong to the public.”

Sen. Sullivan was unable to be there to introduce Balash due to the death of his uncle.

Kevin Meyer files for LG, and look who turns out

0

LABOR AND COMMERCE LEADERS ATTEND: Sen. Kevin Meyer, who started his political career on a local community council, stood before a group of 50 business leaders and announced his candidacy for lieutenant governor on Wednesday.

The group was a fascinating blend of constituencies who gathered in Enstar’s basement meeting room for sandwiches and the announcement.

Conservatives like former Sen. Bill Stoltze, Americans for Prosperity Alaska Director Jeremy Price, and GOP stalwart Randy Ruedrich attended the fundraiser hosted by Enstar CEO John Sims and Curtis Thayer, president of the Alaska Chamber of Commerce.

Also attending were AFL-CIO President Vince Beltrami and Laborers’ Business Manager Joey Merrick.

Neither labor leaders had attended the Sept. 5 fundraiser for Gov. Bill Walker and Lt. Gov. Byron Mallott, whom they supported in 2014. But both stayed to the very end of the fundraiser for Meyer, and had their picture taken with him.

Others who joined the mix of supporters were John Binkley of Fairbanks, a possible candidate for governor; Ryan Binkley, who has formed up a business partnership to save the Alaska Dispatch News from collapsing; Becky Hultberg, president of the Alaska State Hospital and Nursing Home Association; Eddie Grasser of Safari Club International (Alaska), Aves Thompson, President of the Alaska Truckers Association; Tuckerman Babcock, chairman of the Alaska Republican Party; and Moira Smith, who is general counsel at Enstar and the better half of the infamous Democrat Jake Metcalfe, (former chair of Alaska Democratic Party.)

Meyer said he would be running an aggressive campaign and yesterday he launched his campaign website.

Other Republicans who have filed letters of intent to run for LG include Lynn Gattis, who served in the House of Representatives for Wasilla, and Sen. Gary Stevens of Kodiak.

Takeaways from the Rogoff court appearance

11

Alice Rogoff, the owner of the Alaska Dispatch News (and associated companies), made her first in-person appearance in bankruptcy court today, where she answered questions under oath. During previous hearings, she had appeared telephonically.

Dressed in a dark merino wool cardigan, a Pendleton-style, box-pleat skirt, sensible heels, and carrying a well-worn boho bag, Rogoff sat before the U.S. Bankruptcy Court trustee Kathryn Perkins, and revealed as little as possible in her answers.

Some of her responses appeared to be well-coached by her bankruptcy attorney, Cabot Christianson, to whom she has paid $50,000 to handle her affairs as she tries to extract herself from having to pay the tens of millions of dollars in debts she owes.

The questions Rogoff faced today came from a handful of the more than 100 companies to which she owes a great deal of money.

It was a cat-and-mouse game, with creditors asking questions that mystified the audience of reporters, creditors, and curiosity seekers.

But Rogoff’s lawyer knew exactly what the questioners were trying to get at — and he deflected some of the questions by objecting to them, and at other times he jumped in with an answer to keep Rogoff from speaking to a topic herself:

“It’s all in here in excruciating detail,” Christianson said twice, referring to his most recent document filing that explained how the companies Rogoff set up were entwined.

When asked by the court trustee when she knew her business was financially on the rocks, Rogoff unequivocally said she wasn’t in trouble until GCI filed an eviction notice on Aug. 11. She made sure to mention that point twice, so the bankruptcy trustee would be sure to note that the collapse of the business is GCI’s fault.

But a review of the history shows that she stopped paying her bills back in 2015. She ran up unpaid utility bills with GCI at the rate of $1,500 a day and, combined with overdue rent, she was $1.4 million in arrears to the landlord at the place where her press operates on Northway Drive.

“At this time (Nov. 30, 2015) ADN also indicated to GCI that it could not and would not pay a series of unrelated invoices totaling $205,558.00 for work GCI completed on ADN’s new office premises on 31st Avenue (the “31st Avenue Receivable”), again because of a shortage in cash flow,” the eviction complaint said.

“To assist ADN in remaining operational, on January 21, 2016, GCI agreed to a Settlement Agreement pursuant to which GCI CC accepted advertising credits in lieu of cash payment of the 31st Avenue Receivable.”

January, 2016 is also when Rogoff stopped paying her former business partner, Tony Hopfinger, who says she owes him $900,000. He filed a lawsuit a few months later when she decided she didn’t owe him anything further than the $100,000 she had already paid.

Meanwhile, at the GCI building housing the press, her situation continued to deteriorate, according to GCI’s request to the court to assist in evicting the newspaper.

“In an attempt to again support continued operation of ADN, GCI tried to negotiate a second settlement agreement in February of 2016 to provide for repayment of the outstanding Holdover Rent via in-kind advertising credits and permit ADN to remain in the Premises pursuant to this arrangement through April 30, 2017.

“ADN did not agree to GCI’s proposed terms for the second settlement agreement and negotiations ceased at the end of February , 2017.”

“Since February of 2017, GCI has presented alternatives to Rogoff to enable ADN to continue operations and to prevent forcible evictions. None of these alternatives were acceptable to Rogoff.”

Rogoff, according to GCI’s eviction request, had simply stopped negotiating with GCI. She wouldn’t take GCI’s calls. This is the same Rogoff who claimed to the court that she wasn’t in financial trouble until August 2017, when GCI issued the eviction notice.

SHE HAS THE MONEY

Thursday’s proceedings revealed that Rogoff has $1.7 million in personal funds in a Wells Fargo account, and yet chose to borrow up to $1 million from the Binkley Company to keep the newspaper running for a month — including emergency payments to workers, health insurance, and other insurance premiums that were past due.

Although she revealed her investment account balance to the court, Rogoff was unwilling to reveal to the court the details of her marital allowance. She said it was personal and none of the creditors’ business.

But, just as she tried to hide her personal information in an earlier lawsuit filed by her former partner Tony Hopfinger, that marital allowance, believed to be $5 million per year from her estranged husband David Rubenstein, will eventually be made known in a “2004 deposition” (a bankruptcy tool that allows a bankruptcy trustee, a creditor, or debtor to probe for documents relevant to the issues in the case).

Rogoff also is claiming to be a victim of her company and considers herself a creditor. Last month, she said the company owed her $8 million, but this week that amount was increased to more than $12 million which makes her supposedly the largest unsecured creditor of the more than 100 others who are waiting in line to be paid.

ARE THE BINKLEYS BEING USED?

Rogoff told the court that before her bankruptcy filing, she had explored many options for the newspaper, including selling it, developing a joint operating agreement with another company, or creating a nonprofit to operate the paper in the same manner that the Fairbanks Daily NewsMiner operates under the Snedden Foundation.

Rogoff had earlier been negotiating with the  Binkley Company but had walked away from those negotiations earlier in the  summer. It wasn’t until she hit a crisis point with the impending eviction when her attorney called the Binkleys and asked them to save the newspaper, or else the paper that was published the following day would be the final one.

The Binkleys came to the rescue, and got permission from the court and her major creditors to be allowed to loan the newspaper up to $1 million to keep it afloat prior to the bankruptcy auction sale, which occurs Monday in Anchorage. The Binkley Company hopes to be the high bidder.

Meanwhile, Rogoff appears to have been working behind the scenes with other buyers, who will try to outbid the Binkleys for the newspaper, even though they have a purchase agreement with her.

In court, Rogoff did not seem warm to the Binkley Company principle, Ryan Binkley, who sat in the gallery observing the proceedings. She neither greeted nor acknowledged the family that came from Fairbanks and spent their summer trying to save the paper.

Besides the Binkley Company, Steve Malkowich of Alberta Newspaper Group has been spotted in Anchorage doing due diligence on the newspaper assets, and appears to be a credible bidder, according to those close to the newspaper operations.

THE CORPORATE VEIL

Wednesday’s questions from creditors looked to be strategic in attempting to pierce the “corporate veil,” and show that Rogoff was operating the business from her personal accounts, and therefore has personal liability.

Creditors want to get at the $1.7 million in her investment accounts to recover a portion of their losses.

Mark Miller, of M&M Wiring, was particularly interested in the relationship between her attorney, Adam Cook, and the unfinished construction project to install two presses at the 59th and Arctic Blvd building. His company had performed a lot of the wiring at the Arctic Blvd. building, half of which is unpaid.

“Did you authorize Adam Cook to communicate with the contractors and subcontractors during the Arctic project?” asked Miller, who believes he is owed about $500,000 by Rogoff for work his company performed.

Yes, she answered.

“Did you authorize Adam Cook to tell the contractors on the project that they would be paid?” Miller continued.

No, she responded. But Miller was referring to an email from Cook to the contractors, telling them to continue the work and that ADN would pay them. That was his smoking gun.

“At any point in time during the project did Adam Cook step in as project manager in place of Ed McCoy?” Miller asked.

Rogoff hesitated. “Well, not technically,” she said. Cook was her lawyer.

And that may have been exactly the answer that Miller was looking for in showing the court that her attorney from Birch, Horton, Bittner, Cherot was aware of her financial situation and did not act in a responsible manner on her behalf, mixing the job of being her attorney with the role of being her defacto project manager.

Exchanges such as this one were likely mysterious to most court observers, but had real goals for the creditors, who were having their first shot at challenging the woman who is getting ready to stiff them for millions.

Breaking: Ahtna rejects settlement with Walker over Klutina Road

3

Ahtna  has rejected the settlement with the Walker Administration over the public’s historic road access to the Klutina Lake.

This means the 2008 lawsuit over the “RS 2477” access across Ahtna land, that had been interrupted by the proposed settlement, will continue.

According to a press release from the Department of Law today, “After taking extensive public comment on the proposed settlement agreement in the litigation over Klutina Lake Road (officially named Brenwick-Craig Road), settlement negotiations between Ahtna, Inc. and the State have failed. Ahtna, Inc.’s Board of Directors voted to disapprove the proposed settlement.

“I am disappointed that the board was unwilling to come back to the table to see if we could negotiate the final terms of a settlement,” said Attorney General Jahna Lindemuth. “The State has always aimed to preserve public access to the greatest extent possible—whether through settlement or litigation. With Ahtna’s decision, we will now focus our efforts on the litigation.”

The State concluded a 45-day comment period on Aug. 30, and had received more than 400 written comments, and conducted five public meetings, with attendance ranging between 25 and 50 people at each meeting.

The State was still reviewing all the comments when it was informed of the actions taken by the Ahtna board, according to the press release.

The next step in the litigation will be for the parties to submit a status report to superior court by October 31, 2017.

A new trial date will be scheduled by the court.

Alaska Senate President Pete Kelly, Sen. Cathy Giessel (Senate Resources Committee Chair), and Sen. John Coghill (Senate Judiciary Committee Chair) announced in August that they had concerns about Walker’s settlement, which could diminish access to fishing grounds.

[Read: Walker rolls over on Klutina access]

Among their objections, the senators said that Ahtna needed to be held to specific deadlines for fulfilling its end of the obligations in the settlement, such as construction of parking areas for the public. Although the state has timeframes, Ahtna does not.

“Ahtna, unfortunately, historically, has exhibited difficult behavior on this issue in the past (putting up gates, aggressive litigation, issuing citations, delays, etc.). There needs to be accountability,” the senators wrote.

UNFUNDED LIABILITY

“On paper, the state may pursue the agreed upon surveying, construction, etc. But in reality, because of financial constraints, those processes may take years. Meanwhile access to all Alaskans will be restricted, with other viable options being severely limited,” the senators write.

The letter also points out that there is no “true dollar amount” attached to the proposed settlement.  The required funding could be hundreds of thousands, or even millions, but it is unknown.

This may lead to it being thrown out or unfunded, since the governor does not have the power to appropriate — that is a legislative authority. The governor may be putting the state on the hook for millions of dollars in costs at at a time the state is essentially broke.

The Gulkana cemetery issue is also a concern since it was not a part of the original dispute, and the senators pointed out that from a practical standpoint, the land exchange proposed would make it very difficult for vehicles with trailers to turn around, and that if there is future erosion of the access point, the public will be robbed of its access unless the state ensures it has condemnation authority to restore access.

“Many in the Senate were hopeful the state’s interests would be adequately protected during this lawsuit. Upon review of the proposed language, it’s clear the state isn’t there yet. There is still much work to be done,” the letter says.

[Read: Opinion: State rushes settlement on Klutina Road access]

The full settlement agreement is posted on the governor’s web site.