A Seattle-based federal judge has ruled in favor of the Native Village of Eklutna in lawsuit over the tribe’s right to operate a new casino near Anchorage, but the decision may not mark the end of the legal fight.
On July 2 US District Court Judge James L. Robart upheld Eklutna’s federal recognition, rejecting claims from local residents that the tribe lacked the authority to run its Chin’an Gaming Hall.
The casino, which opened in January in a trailer located in a muddy lot, has drawn complaints from nearby Birchwood residents about traffic, noise, and land use. The plaintiffs argued that Eklutna has no legal standing to operate the facility.
In his ruling, Robart cited a 1993 listing by the US Department of the Interior affirming Eklutna’s recognition as a tribe, along with a 1994 Congressional acknowledgment of the department’s authority to determine tribal status. With that recognition affirmed, the tribe may conduct Class II gaming under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act.
The decision means the Chin’an Gaming Hall may continue to operate for now. Attorney Don Mitchell, representing the plaintiffs, filed a motion for reconsideration. If that motion is denied, he indicated that the residents may appeal the ruling.
The case is one of two legal challenges facing Eklutna’s gaming operation.
In a separate lawsuit, the State of Alaska is suing the US Department of the Interior and the Native Village of Eklutna, seeking to overturn a 2024 legal opinion that recognized tribal jurisdiction over Native allotments, a decision that underpins the tribe’s ability to operate the casino.
On April 9, Alaska Attorney General Treg Taylor filed for an injunction to shut down the gaming hall, citing a 2021 federal court ruling that denied Eklutna jurisdiction over the same parcel of land.
That broader case remains unresolved. If the state prevails, it could force the closure of the Chin’an Gaming Hall, which many neighbors in the Birchwood-Eagle River area oppose.
